With over 17 years of MCU productions, which do you find have the most (and least) rewatch value?
Established in 2008, the MCU has produced 37 films and, I think, 17 TV series, including the recent release of Wonder Man. There have also been a couple Special Presentations, like Werewolf by Night, and the Guardians of the Galaxy Holiday special. I'm curious what your favorites, and least favorites are, this far into the franchise.
If you could only access 3 productions, from all of the MCU catelog, what would they be? Conversely, which 3 would you be happy to never sit through again?
(Please refrain from spoilers pertaining to Wonder Man)
If you could only access 3 productions, from all of the MCU catelog, what would they be? Conversely, which 3 would you be happy to never sit through again?
(Please refrain from spoilers pertaining to Wonder Man)
Commentaires
Edit. I misspoke. I meant secret invasion
I think another commenter also confused Invasion with wars
most rewatchable : INFINITY WAR
Least rewatchable: *Secret Invasion* (WTF were they thinking?)
* Spider-Man Homecoming
* Infinity War
* Doctor Strange
\[Honorary Mentions that are fairly interchangeable with the above 3: Guardians of the Galaxy 1, Iron Man 1, Captain America Winter Soldier, Daredevil, and Avengers 1\]
Spider-Man and Doctor Strange are my top two favorite heroes in general. And these two movies are great watches on their own. Spider-Man does require some Civil War and Avengers 1 context, but overall Vulture as a villain holds his own and the interactions between Pete and Toomes still hold up very well. Strange is just a great solo hero intro with fun visuals and a good ending. Infinity War is a great Thanos story and gets a wide variety of cast interactions that I enjoy watching it on its own even if I don't immediately follow up with Endgame.
If I had to pick 3 I could never watch again:
* Secret Invasion
* Antman Quantumania
* Thor Love and Thunder
Its the low hanging fruit, I know, but I'm just cutting out the ones I enjoyed the least. \[(Dis)honorary mentions - Echo, Black Widow, Eternals, Falcon and the Winter Soldier, Captain America Brave New World\]
A lot of these aren't terrible but they were boring, disappointing, or uninteresting enough that I have no interest to rewatch. Secret Invasion is the only one I'd say I avoid because its actually terrible.
As far as your bottom selection, I'm guessing this thread is going to have those listed on repeat.
Least: Secret Invasion - what a mess at every level. I'm not surprised The Marvels completely ignored it
Of all the Marvel Television shows, this one would be the least surprising to me if they retconned it out of continuity given that nobody really liked it, but as of now, it's still canon.
What If season 3 on the other hand completely fumbles the premise of the series at every turn and only delivers a single worthwhile episode.
No joke, I lost count of how many rewatches I'd done once I breezed past 20.
Civil War is just so perfectly done for what i personally want in a comic book movie. The fight scenes are still unmatched
Least- Black Widow
Least rewatchable: Eternals or Thor Love and Thunder
least rewatchable: Quantumania
most rewatchable: GotG 2
Three (others) to keep: Winter Soldier, Ragnarok, Black Panther 1 (with an honorable mention for Thunderbolts\*)
Three (others) to never watch again: Dark World, Love & Thunder, Brave New World
Least rewatched is harder. I try not to rewatch many things as there is so much new creative work to see.
By no means am I saying this is what should've been, but it's just an example. We could've had iron man 3 deal with creating Ultron from the PTSD. It would've been a killer solo movie plot. AOU makes no sense after iron man 3 where he blew up all his suits, pushed his arrogance aside, only for him to overestimate his abilities and make... Evil Drones? They just made him look so stupid. The one bad thing I have to say about the MCU is that when a director takes over from another director, they often undo a lot of the character development.
I remember a lot of the marketing surrounding that movie really propped up the fact that the MCU was turning 10. I can’t believe we’re almost a decade later
"Not that long ago" 😩😆
It hasn’t even been 8 years..
Least Watchable - No Particular Order. Thor Love & Thunder, Quantumanium, Black Panther 2
If you had to boil your list down to 3, what would you say?
Least (one and dones for me): Quantumania, Love and Thunder, Multiverse of Madness
Now, MoM is a title I was not expecting to see on anybody's "least" list but there 100% are no wrong answers. Thank you for your contribution.
I think MoM has a lot of well done technical aspects (unlike the other movies I listed), but the tacked on, contrived Illuminati scene and everything about how Wanda was written really drags it down for me. Not a fan of the America Chavez McGuffin plot either
Least rewatch value: secret invasion, moon knight, hulk
Are you referring to The Incredible Hulk (2008)?
Least rewatch value: secret invasion, moon knight, hulk.
Yea which ever one had liv Tyler
First Avenger
The winter soldier
Avengers 1-4
Ant Man 1 and 2
Thor Ragnarok
Guardians 1 and 2
Civil War
Thunderbolts
First Steps
Deadpool and Wolverine
Wandavision
Least rewatchable
Guardians 3 (too emotional)
Eternals
The Dark World
Secret Invasion
Kill: Brave New World, The Marvels and Secret Invasion
And thank you for your breakdown, I know it's practically impossible with there being so many releases, at this point.
Least rewatchable whatever secret invasion was
Except for you Secret Invasion. Yuck
Least rewatchable: Thor: The Dark World
Least rewatchable. Thor 1-2. (Not the worst MCU movies but i’ve only watched worse ones once.
My tastes are always changing on this. Infinity War and Endgame used to be most rewatchable and i think Guardians will change at some point.
If i could only watch three MCU productions again i would probably choose Thunderbolts, Moon Knight and GOTG 2. (Thunderbolts and Moon Knight are some of my favourite projects that i’ve only seen a few times so i would love to rewatch them a lot more times.
Three that i would be okay never watching again are Spider-Man: Far From Home, The Incredible Hulk and Iron Man 2. (Only chose ones i’ve seen at least twice)
I'm part of the minority that loves IM2. But, there are no wrong answers here, and you 100% nailed the assignment. Thank you for your contribution
No problem this was actually a really good question. It made me realise how many movies in the MCU they are and how my tastes have changed throughout the years
Nonetheless, no wrong answers. Thank you for your input
Aside from that Winter Soldier, Shang Chi, Thunderbolts are on my regular replay list. Loki was definitely the best series by far.
Least watchable…
Secret Invasion… This was a radioactive dumpster fire.
Other low points include Thor: Love and Thunder and Captain America: Brave New World.
Somewhere in the development process, they had a half decent Hulk movie, a half decent Falcon movie, a half decent Captain America movie and a half decent callback to Eternals and then they just blended random pieces together and hoped for the best. Everyone in this film deserved better.
If we are talking about easy to watch when you are only half paying attention… I’m probably going with GotG, Shang-Chi, Marvels or Thunderbolts because those films just feel like you are hanging out with cool friends.
The Extended Edition Lord of the Rings laughs at this statement...
But overall, it has to be the four Avengers movies and Civil War.
And obviously least is Secret Invasion cmon.
Endgame (I know it's full of fan-service, but I love watching them win),
Thor: Ragnarok (Despite L&T's travesty, I will never not find this chapter entertaining)
Least:
Eternals (I can't imagine getting to a point where I can watch it without shouting things at the screen)
Love and Thunder (I loved the opening, but almost didn't make it to the end of the movie)
* Avengers
* Ant-Man and the Wasp
* Infinity War
* No Way Home
* Multiverse of Madness (unironically love this movie)
* Deadpool and Wolverine
I can't say if I'll ever try to watch Eternals again, just didn't keep me entertained.
It's probably a top 5 Marvel movie for me.
Least: Thor L&T
Least: Black Panther 2. I just found it to be boring and too long.
**1. Avengers: Endgame** – This is the ultimate culmination of everything that came before. The stakes, the character arcs, the action—it’s one of the most satisfying blockbusters ever made.
**2. Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse** (though technically not MCU, it feels like it fits!) – Visually stunning, emotionally packed, and a fresh take on the Spider-Man mythos. One of the most creative and impactful superhero movies.
**3. The Winter Soldier** – This movie completely changed the tone of the MCU and elevated the stakes for Cap. It’s also a fantastic political thriller that holds up even outside of the superhero genre.
As for the three I’d be okay never watching again:
**1. Thor: The Dark World** – Just didn’t click for me. It felt like the plot was dragged along by basic tropes, and the villain was forgettable. Honestly, I don’t think it added much to the overall MCU.
**2. Iron Man 3** – The twist with the Mandarin really rubbed me the wrong way. The tone felt all over the place, and it didn’t feel like the solid follow-up I wanted after *The Avengers*.
**3. Eternals** – This one was ambitious, but it felt more like an art film than a typical MCU entry. I didn’t connect with the characters as much as I expected, and it was just a bit too slow for my taste.
It’s crazy how much the MCU has evolved, and while some of the earlier entries are a bit rough around the edges, I think they've only gotten better in terms of character development and storytelling.
Least love and thunder
Captain America: Winter Soldier
Captain America: Civil War
Least rewatchable:
Thor: Love and Thunder
Most rewatchable Series:
Daredevil
Hawkeye
Least rewatchable:
Secret Invasion
Echo
I'm not really a lover of mantle-passing, (just kind of a 'me' thing) but I really am hoping we don't just abandon the character of Kyet Beeshop.
Least Rewatchable: Secret Invasion
I'll never watch SI again, tried and stopped rewatching eternals and thor 4.
All Time: Infinity War
TV Show: Falcon and the Winter Soldier
Post Endgame movie: Thunderbolts
Least
All time: Thor The Dark World
TV Show: Echo
Post Endgame: Quantumania
Least Rewatchable: ETERNALS, THOR LOVE & THUNDER, ANT-MAN & THE WASP QUANTUMMANIA, Secret Invasion
Least rewatchable: Secret Invasion (seriously what the hell were they thinking with this one?)
Secret Invasion - least rewatch
Ironheart, Ms.Marvel, The Marvels, Agents of Shield, Marvel's Inhumans, She-Hulk, Ironfist, Luke Cage, Defenders, Helstrom, Cloak & Dagger, Runaways and Echo.
Ironheart and Ms.Marvel are both a disaster...I still don't know what happened there.
Second would be Guardians of the Galaxy…1? Maybe 2? Or 3? There is so much growth among all the characters from one movie to the next and I love that aspect so much. By Vol. 3 everyone has grown and matured and accepted the curve balls that life can throw your way.
Third is tough…I mean, Winter Soldier rules but it’s also so intense. I have a soft spot for Ant-Man and the Wasp because Scott is the best dad and it has Walton Goggins in it (can we PLEASE get Goggins and Sam Rockwell back in an MCU movie again for Christs sake? Preferably as a villain team up? And I love Civil War, but I think I’d go with Spider-Man Homecoming. It’s such a great love letter to John Hughes movies, it’s the best live action Peter Parker and Spidey, Michael Keaton rules, “The talk” is one of the best and most chilling MCU scenes ever, and it’s wonderful watching Peter grow into this role.
The three I’d avoid are Thor Love and Thunder because of how disappointing it was coming off of Ragnarok which could have easily made the rewatch list. It’s also just so…not good. It fails on many levels. Low hanging fruit would be the Eternals, so instead I’ll say Iron Man 2 because it feels longer than Endgame and it’s actually pretty short. Doctor Strange and the Multiverse of Madness. For a movie with multiverse in the title we sure didn’t get a lot of that, Cumberbatch’s wig took me out of every scene, and I can’t get over the complete randomness of introducing Charlize Theron as a character barely anyone knows, which is the reoccurring theme of the last couple phases.
Least rewatchable - Echo, Marvels, and Echo again because Echo.
- Civil War
- Avengers 1-4
- No way home
- DP and W
- Hawkeye
- Ragnarok
Least:
- Thor1-2
-
I am more a show person than a movie person, I watched most of the movies just once. On the contrary, many of the shows I watched them more than once, particularly those of the old Marvel TV. DD is top in the count, miles ahead of the second, I must have watched it 12 times when it was in Netflix, and once a year since it is in Disney+. The whole 47 episodes, without even skipping the intro.
The least I'd say is Secret Invasion, I havven't even watched it complete.
Least: Ms Marvel, Secret Invasion, Ironheart.....what a waste of time and resources.
least: ant man 3
But as for more centrally MCU things, my go-to’s are *Ragnarok* and *Infinity War*. (And after those, NWH and MoM.)
Someday in a hazy future, I’ll force myself to watch *Quantumania* or L&T again, but I’m sure not looking forward to them.
Me, trying to look past L&T
Least - Wakanda Forever. It is literal garbage.
It has *no baggage*. Its just a clean comics romp and you can start to appreciate a lot of the threads you know are coming down the line.
**Best movie: CA:TWS**
Could honestly work as a standalone espionage flick. Has the best legs to stand without the backing of *the universe*.
**Worst movie: Thor4**.
I will never forgive them for how they handled Janes worthiness, the child soldiers, the deux-ex machina, the bungling of one of the MCU's best villains. This movie was hurt the most by *potential*. Talk about spiking the football.
1. Ant-Man. Yes, the firrst Ant-Man movie. Very high rewatch value and one of the better standalone MCU movies. I do like my heist movies.
2. Captain America: The First Avenger. I DO like Iron Man and what it contributed to the MCU, but Cap is my favourite OG Avengers movie.
3. Thunderbolts\*. It's just good.
Low rewatch value:
1. Secret Invasion. A big disappointment compared to what I expected it to be. They should've made it an "Avengers scale" movie instead. Big mistake to >!kill off Maria Hill!<. I mainly get annoyed when this one is mentioned.
2. Thor: The Dark World and Thor: Love and Thunder. Thor hasn't been fairly handeled in the MCU. The Dark Word is by far one of the weakest MCU entries, storwise according to me. And I did like the humour in Thor Ragnarok, Love and Thunder took the "humour" waaaaay to far. I mean, Stormbreaker being jelous of Mjölnir? That subplot was just *terribly stupid*.
3. Deadpool and Wolverine. Yep, might be a hot take. Yes, it was a glorious cameo and fan service fest. But I never cared for the actual story and Marvel hinted big promises, but it didn't deliver.
least rewatchable from the things i've watched is probably Ms.Marvel, show wasn't bad but not good enough for me to rewatch
agree that secret invasion isa 1 and and never done again offering.
Personally, I'd recommend anyone who is NOT a completionist, to just go ahead and skip Secret Invasion. I honestly don't even remember if there was anything to really take away that is expected to have any bearing on upcoming material
Least is probably the eternals
least rewatchable literally everything released after Avengers Endgame
Least: Dr. Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, Black Widow, Brave New World, Secret Invasion, Hawkeye, She-Hulk, Falcon and the Winter Soldier, Eternals, The Marvels, Iron Heart, What If...?, Thor: Love and Thunder
But that's me.
For an answer I've already seen, but is the correct answer is thor love and thunder. Imo the absolute worst movie to come out of the mcu