What if Iron man died from thanos snap?

Did dr strange take a gamble by giving up the time stone to thanos? Or was iron man not a part of the 50/50 of the snap since dr strange asked thanos to spare him?

If ironman died from the snap, it would have all failed?

Edit: Maybe I didn’t word my question well, seems to have caused some confusion. What I’m wondering is, was Ironman a part of the 50/50 snap gamble? Or was he guaranteed to live since Dr strange asked thanos to spare his life when he gave up the time stone.

Voir le contenu lié

Commentaires

Captain-Wilco2026-01-17 03:15

Sorry, best I can do is “What if Captain Carter fought Dr. Strange”, or “What if this character took on an identity belonging to a different, arbitrarily-chosen character”.

YaBoiPokeJuns2026-01-17 03:29

We should've got a Ruins adaptation in What If.

Sylar_Lives2026-01-17 03:16

Without Tony how would they have figured out time travel? It’s pretty much over.

PointBreakvsLebowski2026-01-17 03:16

Dr Strange went forward in time to see all the scenarios of the coming conflict. He knew Tony had to be alive in order to win the only one he saw them winning. He also knows that events of the present can change the future, so he gave the stone to Thanos.

LordZoldyck2026-01-17 03:17

No he didn’t take a gamble he literally said that out of all the possibilities there was only one outcome where they win. So yes, if iron man got snapped they would have failed.

AdhesivenessTotal3402026-01-17 03:17

Strange knew who would be snapped. He knew everything that needed to occur or else we would’ve gotten a completely different movie and plot. Hence Peter when he sees Tony saying something like he didn’t remember what happened, but he was just there and Strange said they had to go. Strange knew what to do the moment he came back and obviously where to portal, plus gather everyone.

Kthron2026-01-17 03:19

Maybe each version had a different snap list

JagwarRocker2026-01-17 03:21

"It was the only way"

Morgoth18142026-01-17 03:26

Strange knew the one scenario that they’d win. If there were none, then no one at would he give it up.

Chaoticgood7902026-01-17 03:26

Dr. Strange saw the one outcome which would also tell him Tony survived the initial snap

Stunnzu2026-01-17 03:34

But he had no control over the snaps powers. The snap could have wiped Ironman too

Chaoticgood7902026-01-17 03:37

What? He saw 14 million possibilities. He basically set that one possibility in motion with his next steps by giving up the time stone. It’s not just the snap that is by chance. He saw all the actions that also led to that point. He directly influenced the path they went down

eagc72026-01-17 03:44

Doctor Strange: Oh fuck

Ultron_Sentry_092026-01-17 13:06

Then I’d be one happy neural construct