Director Cut?

I’ve seen Iron Man countless times on Disney+ and home media, but watching it on FX right now has me noticing something interesting.

There are a lot of additional scenes inserted to stretch the TV runtime.

Why have we never gotten proper director’s cuts of some of our favorite Marvel films?

Voir le contenu lié

Commentaires

dbkenny4262026-01-16 16:26

That's just not something Marvel Studios seems interested in doing.

LonesomeBulldog2026-01-16 16:26

These aren't really director-driven movies where the resulting movie is the director's "vision". They are generally just hired guns.

After_Dig_75792026-01-16 16:28

😑🙄😒

zero_eternal2026-01-16 16:30

[deleted]

Least_Rain80272026-01-16 16:45

X-Men flashbacks

matty_nice2026-01-16 17:00

Well you had one of their main producers who said that it's a red flag if writers are a fan of Marvel.

So not sure exactly what you would have expected otherwise. Lol.

zero_eternal2026-01-16 17:08

Well, I would assume that these directors and writers would at least *try* to read up on the chosen events for their project and the particular histories and motivations of their leading characters.

No one said they had to be a fan, but I am inclined to think they still did their research, even at the very least.

knotsteve2026-01-16 16:29

In general, Marvel directors take the position that the release version IS the director's cut. The extended cut of Iron Man for FX was a one-off.

UnhingedHippie2026-01-16 16:29

The fans won’t stop arguing. You want to add different versions of the movies for people to argue what’s canon or not?

Dave_Eddie2026-01-16 16:32

Because 90% of the time the version released *is* the directors cut.

If you mean 'why arent we getting a version with all the extra bits they use to fill out run time' then thats a different question and the answer is usually 'because there's no demand or not enough return to justifying the additional costs.

revolutionaryartist42026-01-16 16:44

I don’t think you understand what a director’s cut actually means. It doesn’t mean all cut scenes are included in the movie, it means the director didn’t have approval of the final cut and in a director’s cut, they do.

To fill the time slot, movies aired on broadcast will often utilize cut scenes, even if the director didn’t intend for them to be there.

Compare Richard Donner’s director’s cut of Superman with the three-hour TV edit. Donner himself denounced the TV version because it incorporated a lot of scenes he felt ruined the overall pacing and feel of the film.

Salarian_American2026-01-19 22:57

Someone once asked Kevin Smith if there was ever going to be a director's cut of Dogma, and he said something like "the theatrical release *is* the director's cut. I was in the editing room the whole time."

AKluthe2026-01-16 18:06

I have always believed Marvel has refused to do secondary releases that restore cut scenes because they don't want to deal with which release is canon to everything that follow.

BaronZhiro2026-01-16 20:44

Sony, on the other hand…

John7117112026-01-16 23:11

Disney on the other hand...
Remember Endgame started it

CaptHayfever2026-01-17 04:57

The Endgame re-release had 1 scene tacked on after the movie was over, without finished CGI, & with an introduction that explicitly said it was a deleted scene.
The Far From Home & No Way Home re-releases had the extra scenes spliced into the story.
Those aren't the same thing.

John7117112026-01-17 05:46

They had the same exact goal however the dream of all studios.
The quest for more money.

Jenkes_of_Wolverton2026-01-17 11:52

Fourteen million six hundred and five different editions of Endgame, all in one handy tesseract boxset, with complementary flerkin and Groot plushy figures. Ker-ching!

ABC_Dildos_Inc2026-01-16 18:37

It's a movie that began production with only some ideas for things like set pieces.

They were literally writing or rewriting scripts each day.

There was no artistic vision that was left on the cutting room floor.

mrbaryonyx2026-01-17 00:11

It's crazy how that happens.

I remember when I watched Batman Begins on FX but it also fell short of the tv runtime, so every twenty minutes they would cut to a woman talking to the camera about antidepressants

Far_Adeptness98842026-01-17 02:17

What extra scenes?