Does Sir Patrick Stewart as Charles Xavier hold the record for most number of times an actor has performed the death of the same character across multiple different stories/narratives?
By my count, between 2006 and 2022, Sir Patrick Stewart's Charles Xavier was killed off on-screen *at least* three, and *possibly* four times:
1. Vaporized by Jean Grey in *X-men: The Last Stand*.
2. About to vaporized by Sentinels in *X-men: Days of Future Past* just before the timeline resets (and the timeline reset arguably "kills" that version of Xavier anyway).
3. Stabbed to death by X-24 in *Logan*.
4. Neck snapped by Wanda Maximoff in *Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness*.
I honestly can't think of another actor who's performed the death of the same character across multiple *different* productions/stories/narratives.
Do you think we're going to see the fifth (and final) death of Stewart's Xavier in *Avengers Doomsday* or *Avengers Secret Wars*?
1. Vaporized by Jean Grey in *X-men: The Last Stand*.
2. About to vaporized by Sentinels in *X-men: Days of Future Past* just before the timeline resets (and the timeline reset arguably "kills" that version of Xavier anyway).
3. Stabbed to death by X-24 in *Logan*.
4. Neck snapped by Wanda Maximoff in *Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness*.
I honestly can't think of another actor who's performed the death of the same character across multiple *different* productions/stories/narratives.
Do you think we're going to see the fifth (and final) death of Stewart's Xavier in *Avengers Doomsday* or *Avengers Secret Wars*?
Commentaires
And when savage lands suppressed his powers in the animated movies.
I can conclude his mutant power is to be a paraplegic.
Live Die Repeat was just the tag line.
However, much like Star Wars and Raiders of the Lost Ark, retitling a movie after it's release doesn't actually change the registered name of the film itself. It will always officially be *Edge of Tomorrow.*
Edit: I got 14 on the first count with Strange vs Dormammu (could be off) and his variant died at the beginning of Doctor Strange and the Multiverse of Madness
Daisy Johnson in AoS died 16 times lol
And presumably he died in at least some percentage of the 14,000,605 possible futures he experienced in Infinity War.
Also while we’re at it, what an insane ratio for what is essentially one (not) dude vs earth’s mightiest heroes.
Source: https://www.wtaj.com/news/groundhog-day/things-you-might-not-know-about-groundhog-day-the-bill-murray-movie/
Even if off screen deaths counted, then Groundhog Day still wins because he had thousands more deaths than Dr Strange. Strange viewing the possible outcomes does not mean he actually experienced those deaths.
Yeah som how his corpse remained behind after each death.
So dying once every 3 weeks for billions of years. One hell of a bird indeed.
Groundhog Day, and other deaths within a time-loop story, are also not what I'm talking about here since those deaths are all within the context of the same story/narrative/production.
Also based on how they are misunderstanding the question the real thing to point out is Picard dies on TNG due to resets and time loop shenanigans at least five times so this wouldn't even be Sir Patrick's most impressive role, but that is not what you meant.
But he has been voiced by two different actors.
They both had *very* long careers, often played villains, and Price died in his last film role in *Edward Scissorhands*.
- Died for a moment in S2, was saved before taken to the afterlife
- Killed on a loop by Loki hundreds of times in S3
- Died and went to Hell in S3
- Future Dean is killed by Satan in S5
- Died and went to Heaven in S5
- Died for a moment in S6, was saved before taken to the afterlife
- Died in S9 and became a demon
- Killed for good in the last episode of S15
But there's a bunch more. He dies in about 15 episodes over the course of the series.
* His original death is seen on screen in "Me²".
* He gets resurrected as a human and dies again in "Timeslides".
* All the characters fade out as they get erased when the timeline resets back to an earlier point at the end of "White Hole".
* We see the whole crew die in a crash in "Back to Reality" (though this turns out to be a hallucination).
* His hologram form gets killed by the crew's future selves in "Out of Time".
* He plays his Ace Rimmer alternate version from a parallel universe, who dies in "Stoke Me a Clipper".
* His resurrected human form dies again at the end of "Only the Good". (Well, he meets the Grim Reaper, but you might not count that as dying because he's last seen kneeing Death in the groin before running away.)
* We see him dying in "Back to Earth" (although that's quickly revealed to be a narrated vision).
* Multiple copies of him get merged into a monster (their multiple heads still voiced by Barrie), which is killed at the end of "Officer Rimmer".
Even though all these examples take place in the same continuity with the same writer, you could technically count the last two as a "different production" because they had switched TV channels (from the BBC to Dave), and the latter gained an additional co-production company.
Other versions of him die in the later Red Dwarf novels Last Human and Backwards. But unfortunately they can't be counted because their audiobook editions weren't read by Chris Barrie like the first two audiobooks had been.
I can think of at least 3 times Picard died, and I wouldn't be surprised if there are more.
T1, T2, T3 for sure. The one in Salvation (who only briefly has CGI'd Arnie face). One of the Arnie Terminators in Genisys (which is meant to be the same as the T1 version). And Dark Fate.
Then again, they aren't really " distinct individuals" aren't they? They're all inhabited by the same AI system in identical bodies that come off an assembly line (literally!) Sure, they have different experiences and then evolve in different ways, but one could say the same about Charles Xavier in different timelines/universes I suppose.
So I dunno...lot to wrap one's head around here.
Debateable, but definitely not an example I can dismiss off-hand.
Timeline A: First Class, X-Men, X2, The Last Stand, The Wolverine, DoFP
Timeline B: First Class, DoFP, Apocalypse, Dark Phoenix, some unclear drastically altered version of X-Men and X2, Deadpool 1 and 2, then Logan.
Timeline C: same as B, but with 616 and Endgame rippling over and causing Deadpool and Wolverine and Doomsday to alter things massively

Lets roll with this.
IMHO,
1. Blink
2. Midnight
3. Heaven Sent
\- Stabbed by Loki
>!\- Faked his death (IIRC, been a while since I've seen this part of the show)!<
>!\- Appeared to have died when he teleported to the ghost dimension!<
>!\- LMD replica died in an explosion!<
>!\- Died from a punch from an LMD!<
>!\- Died as a deal with Ghost Rider to remove his alien ressurection blood!<
>!\- Alternate universe / clone / cosmic god avatar (idk what's going on in season 6) was shot at and killed!<
>!\- Same entity (again idk) died at the end of season 6, I never rewatched this season I'm sorry!<
>!\- "Dying's kind of my superpower", dies!<
>!\- LOTS of deaths in the time loop episode "As I Always Have Been" (goat)!<
Because of various plotlines introduced in the show, the line between what does and doesn't count as a Coulson death is pretty blurry, but I'd say there's 4 solid, absolute, inarguable deaths, those being the 2nd, 6th, 7th, and 10th ones listed. Could be more I'm not aware of
Dormammu, I’ve come to bargain.
Or Thanos if you count What If and MoM, tho those weren’t performances.
This is doing a lot of heavy lifting.
Freddy has a bunch, but arguably he is dead the whole time, so I'm not sure if it counts. But at least it is all the same actor.
TNG S5: Dies in 1800s San Franscico when his head is blown off. (gets better in S6E1)..
Nemesis: Dies and body gets blown up real good.
Picard S1: Somehow Data returns... and then dies.
Picard S3: Somehow Data returns as a "real boy (old man)"... and then his consciousness dies to an attack by Lore in the same body, but then somehow Data returns because he turned Lore into himself.
They even lampshade it in Picard S3 after getting the old-man "golem" body onto their ship. I think it is Riker who says "Wait, didn't you die at least twice already?" (paraphrase from memory)
If Daniel Jackson and Phil Coulson are on the list, Data is right there at about the same point on the list.