Imagine how terrifying the snap was for the aliens on planet.
The snap affected people on a UNIVERSAL scale.
The earth had it easier than most planets because the people of earth knew what was happening, they had someone to blame.
Imagine you are an alien living 10 solar systems away from earth, you are just living life like every other day and you’re at home and your family just disappears.
You don’t know why they’re gone, the government can’t tell you, no one knows. it just happened randomly.
Then 5 human years later, your family just reappears with no explanation.
Also imagine if 5 human years is 500 years for another race. If you are the alien who got snapped, everyone you knew might be gone.
The earth had it easier than most planets because the people of earth knew what was happening, they had someone to blame.
Imagine you are an alien living 10 solar systems away from earth, you are just living life like every other day and you’re at home and your family just disappears.
You don’t know why they’re gone, the government can’t tell you, no one knows. it just happened randomly.
Then 5 human years later, your family just reappears with no explanation.
Also imagine if 5 human years is 500 years for another race. If you are the alien who got snapped, everyone you knew might be gone.
Commentaires
But then again, this is a story concept that really starts to fall apart the more you think of it. Like what happened to people who were snapped in moving vehicles, sick in hospitals, imprisoned, or a domestic abuser reappeared, etc. At some point, you’d have to say “hey, it ain’t that kinda movie”
But I do think Marvel has been uneven in dealing with the fallout of the snap
Series doing things on their own like She-Hulk, Moonknight and Werewolf By Night were the way to go (notwithstanding individual shows' quality). That was the good format.
The Guardians Christmas Special was also a good use of characters in a TV special because the events of the shows aren't required for GotG3; it's not required viewing.
Introducing Ms Marvel and Photon in two different shows and then involving them in the main MCU narrative in The Marvels, for instance, was a mistake.
I’m fully of the belief that the movies should be the only required viewing to get the complete story, and that D+ shows help or enhance the story but if you don’t watch them you don’t miss anything important.
A MCU series about the snap would fall into that same category. Unfortunately that’s not what happened and we have shows that are required, which undercut the movies as you said.
The Marvel writers came up with a truly universe destroying plotpoint that would just snowball into overly complicated scripts.
So instead, everyone on Earth was really sad for 5 years, and there is some minor terroism after everyone returns. Extremely unbelievable and kind of disspointing that as an audience we have to kind of ignore just HOW impactful the Thanos Snap was.
Damn, that sounds like a very cool world to explore the morality of vigilantism, and "heros".
The pandemic showed the cracks in society and the snap is an excellent allegory to COVID. That survivors group that Steve is hosting at the beginning of Endgame looks a lot like various support groups that popped up. The realization that the people who were there to save us, to protect us… simply didn’t care enough? Not sure Disney has the stones for that.
That would get very repetitive if they all had to focus on that plot point. And keep highlighting the impossibility of it all. The Snap and Blip would be world ending catastrophes in reality (especially if it affect non-sentient life, we won't even go there).
A brief 20-second montage, a lamentation of various aliens and weird biologicals going "poof" at the beginning of Endgame would have elevated the whole enterprise.
Ending poignantly with some bizarre creature moaning in dismay in an empty cave, ash drifting around it
Season 1 is based accurately on a great novel.
S2 and s3 came up with a way to extend the plot and change it radically each season and bring the show to a fantastic concludion.
Also the point of the show is not or why it happened. It's strictly examining the human reactions to what happened and the differences in how people react.
It's one of the best prestige tv shows of all time.
Personally, I would've loved a season of Hawkeye for every year of it, as he makes his way around the world, taking his revenge on the "unworthy" survivors
They'd have zero clue what was happening and probably build new religions around the snap and the return.
Why they didn’t make a GOTG style series showing the effects of the blip on knowhere I will never know. Or literally even another Captain marvel movie since we hear her say in endgame that she’s been busy helping all these planets. I WANTED TO SEE THAT. Nobody in space knew what was happening on earth. At least the surviving avengers were able to tell the remaining humans about what happened, but the rest of the galaxy, hell the rest of the universe have no idea. Everyone just vanished with no explanation. Sure Carol could go around and spread the word but that’s ALOT of space to cover, and she likely never left the galaxy.
Marvel dropped the ball hard when it came to the blip. After endgame all they wanted to do was push it under the bed and move on from it forever when they shouldnt have. Nothing, not even the marvel universe with how wacky it is would recover as fast as it did post snap/blip. It’s like it never even happened. Everyone went back to normal like they didn’t just lose 5 years of their life. There should have been global wars fought, wars in space too.
But instead…
The Marvels sure was a movie that happened.
I definitely see the positives, and Kamala is amazing in it, but I personally don’t think it’s a movie that will make someone like Carol if they didn’t like her going into it.
The stones aren't like a genie who you tell your wish to and who grants wishes based on its own interpretation of what is spoken. They carry out the intent of the person using them.
Given the overpopulation and overconsumption issues that Thanos gave as his reason for his actions there would be no real reason to include "gods."
*two weeks later*
Anyways...
For the lazy:
>r-selected species, species whose populations are governed by their biotic potential (maximum reproductive capacity, r).
>
>...
>
>The production of numerous small offspring followed by exponential population growth is the defining characteristic of r-selected species. They require short gestation periods, mature quickly (and thus require little or no parental care), and possess short life spans. Unlike K-selected species, members of this group are capable of reproduction at a relatively young age; however, many offspring die before they reach reproductive age.
[Source](https://www.britannica.com/science/r-selected-species)
It’s been indicated more than once how earth is a unique and special place in the galaxy, with how strongly Asgard protected it, how Ego only successfully bred a son with an earth woman, how multiple infinity stones wound up here naturally. Earth was the center of the convergence of the realms in Dark World. Earth was the favorite planet of multiple pantheons of gods. Earth was the origin of all of the most significant heroes outside of Thor, who alone stood up to Thanos and intimidated the Kree enough to keep them away. Earth was the planet whose Eternals stood up to Arishem. Earth is where Kang, the most significant person in the entire multiverse, originated from. His TVA was mainly staffed with humans from Earth. Even outside of 616 cosmic powers like Knull, Galactus, and the Phoenix force are drawn to Earth. It’s shown at times that the larger galactic civilization is aware of “Terra” but seem to avoid any direct contact, like we are some sort of primitive tribe in the Amazon rainforest.
For whatever reason, Earth is just an extremely special place in the grand scheme of things.
Because it probably makes for a better read if the reader can relate.
I think that's also why Star Wars, set in a galaxy far away with a plethora of different alien species, still has most of their main characters as humans.
And to think, the Celestials wanted to destroy it.
Then, like when everyone returns, would those people on the flight fall into the water?
Would the earth be at the same point of rotation for those folks to be in that spot? (Like when Hulk did the snap to return everyone, it wasn't the 5th anniversary day of everyone disappearing. It seemed like it was any day. Hypothetically, Thanos's snap could have happened in summertime or spring, but when Hulk snapped everyone back, that could've been 5 years plus, right? Maybe even in Fall if not winter. )
Let's say even without the rotation talk. There's thousands of flights taking place worldwide at any given hour. If folks from flights got snapped along with everyone else. Where would they return to? Especially if they were on a flight that was flying over an ocean?
What about if anyone was underwater in a submarine?
I think its one of those things maybe I shouldn't overthink it but ive wondered about it for a while.
The rest of the universe... half of life turned to dust one day, and then five years later returned exactly as it had been, and they NEVER KNEW WHY IT HAPPENED.
No....they didn't.
Let's say you are a prime minister before you were snapped
Then you return back but there is new prime minister now.
Would you be willing to give up your position?
It would lead to so many riots everywhere
The worldbuilding failure that was not exploring the snap was such a miss.
We shouldnt have had the Multiverse Era following Endgame, we should have had the Snap Era.
We get one or two lines to throw it off. It’s pathetic writing.
Black Widow should’ve been a movie about Natasha dealing with the responsibility of running the Avengers during this time, and it reminding her of how she failed her sister all those years ago. Maybe she is distraught when she realizes her sister got dusted but then realizes Yelena was investigating some red room stuff and starts following those threads. Could’ve even incorporated Hawkeye/Ronin into this. Other projects could’ve also taken place during this time with minimal changes. And then after few years, they bring everyone back for Endgame.
No they didn't lol.
Nick Fury didn't know what was happening with the snap.
They only figured it out later when the surviving Avengers told the world.