I can’t get into the MCU universe because of one specific reason
Hi everyone. I recently decided to watch the MCU from the start so I could be more up to date with new releases. I began with Iron Man and was surprised by how difficult it was for me to sit through, mostly because of how women are written and presented.
I was aware of the criticism around early MCU films, but the level of sexualization and gender dynamics made it hard to stay immersed.
I’m curious whether others felt the same when revisiting these movies, and whether the portrayal of female characters meaningfully improves later on.
I was aware of the criticism around early MCU films, but the level of sexualization and gender dynamics made it hard to stay immersed.
I’m curious whether others felt the same when revisiting these movies, and whether the portrayal of female characters meaningfully improves later on.
Commentaires
Thor and First Avenger introduce very strong and intelligent female characters who are not sexualized.
For more recent films, both Thunderbolts\* and Fantastic Four have incredibly dynamic and powerful female leads who aren't sexualised at all
Now, whether one considers female characters to be *well-written* overall is up for debate and really comes down to personal preference; but the whole "womanizing is cool" thing is pretty much limited to early Tony Stark, and he improves over time.
(Personally, as far as female characters go, I absolutely LOVE Natasha, Yelena Belova, Carol Danvers, Monica Rambeau, Wanda Maximoff, Kamala Khan, Sue Storm, and Kate Bishop. Nebula is also pretty high on my list. I consider all of them to be pretty well written overall.)
P.S.Men were more sexualised than women, it's not even a competition.
There's a type of post that shows up on the internet which is completely vague but it seems like it's making an accusation. It's designed to kind of make people nod and say "yeah it is problematic" without ever really giving any examples or details. I do not know what they mean by gender dynamics or even sexualization.
Was Pepper sexualized at all? Was Jane Foster? Peggy Carter certainly wasn't. I would argue that even Natasha in Iron Man 2 wasn't because she was playing a role which was designed to dupe Tony - a famous poon hound. There's no definition and certainly not one that holds up when the guys are dehydrating themselves for their shirtless scenes in damned near every movie.
Also, if by gender dynamics they mean that women are weak in comparison to men in these movies that's not a great argument to make when the male characters are super soldiers, sorcerer Supremes and a literal god.
Were you even alive during the 90' or before that?
If the MCU were to be historically accurate, boy you would be shocked how women were really treated in reality.
Captain Marvel, Black Widow, Eternals, The Marvels and Thunderbolts are female-led or directed and have female writers or co-writers. Black Panther: Wakanda Forever is female-led.
Out of all other writers/directors, I think Russo brothers and Ryan Coogler are the best at making well-written female characters. Captain America: The Winter Soldier is a way better introduction to Natasha (aka Black Widow) than Iron Man 2 and a much better movie too. They also directed Captain America: Civil War, Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame and were respectful there too. And all of Black Panther's supporting female characters are great and there's a lot of them!
I personally also greatly enjoyed Thor movies, especially the first two, I think Jane, Darcy and Sif in them are great. Ant-Man is fun, and Ant-Man and The Wasp has a female co-lead technically, though tbh I don't remember if the narrative actually follows her.
Absolutely avoid anything by Joss Whedon and James Gunn though.