I actually love The Eternals
I love the opening scene with them fighting the Deviant in ancient Mesopotamia. I love the design of the Deviant, and how its multiple eyes are reminiscent of Arishem. I love the first scene in the present with Sersi and its use of Pink Floyd's "Time", and then the scene with Sersi and Sprite and Dane. I think that the initial characterization is superb, and that the cinematography is absolutely gorgeous.
I simply don't understand how this movie can be hated. Sure, I think it could have been done better as a D+ show, but I'm more than happy with what we were given.
I simply don't understand how this movie can be hated. Sure, I think it could have been done better as a D+ show, but I'm more than happy with what we were given.
Commentaires
L&T works for me personally as it is being told from the pov of Korg :)
I also disagree with people who say Thor is too goofy in it. He's an overly traumatized by loss goofball who still has a ton of heart and good intentions. At this point he's lived for thousands of years, and over what is basically the last month or so, he lost his entire family, home, eye, felt responsible for the death of literally half the universe due to his hubris, lost his hammer, got a new axe, lost 2 of his new best friends, fell in love and pushed her away because he was scared, and started hanging out with some weirdos who all shared a connection he didn't feel. Nothing is really phasing him by L&T, until it does.
On a side note I’m really happy for the acknowledgement of Love in the Doomsday trailer; I’m really hoping that the threads in Eternals (Arishems Judgement, Black Knight, and Harry styles) all get picked up on at some point - the sooner the better :)
When i saw it in theaters, that ending with Arishem over Earth had my cackling with delight, like HOLY SHIT that was one of the craziest moments of the entire MCU
They did a great job of introducing and developing every character, in my opinion.
But like I said, the character stuff is a lot of fun and I am reminding myself I need to watch this again.
Now whats confirmed is Thanos IS an eternal. Which i understand how some can think he wasnt given how vague the whole titan ordeal was in Infinity War. & not to mention how the Titans were portrayed as just a normal civilization that grew too big & died due to overpopulation. That deviant gene aspect can still exist. I believe it does, its the only thing that makes him make sense. So many connections there lol
Eternals is the only MCU project I've chosen to collect Funko Pops for.
It's also what I would pick if hard-pressed to choose an Absolute Favorite MCU project.
Found it to be very "meh " But I also don't like that Marvel seems to be sweeping it under the rug.
It's big problem is it tried to introduce too many characters at one time and failed to make most of them interesting. But some of the characters like Kingo, Makkari, Druig, and Thena made a big enough impression that I want to see them again.
Even Kit Harrington, as future Black Knight Dane Whitman, deserves more attention. He could be a gateway drug to Marvel Comics UK heroes like Captain Britain and MI-13.
It's past time for Marvel to go global.
And Kit Harington should have had a bigger role. The audience needed a non-Eternal insert character to join the story.
Also, the final fight is basically a Justice League fight done right. It's what Flash, Cyborg, Wonder Woman, Superman and Dr. Fate would look like in battle if done competently.
But I think if they re-introduced the Eternals while focussing on their most appealing asset to casual audiences being their Justice League level battles and this time against some X-Men, it could give at least a couple of them a proper second chance in the MCU

Welcome to the team ^^ I really love this movie too, visually so much better than some that came after, although unfortunately there are one or two slow moments that spoil the enjoyment. I like the cast, but unfortunately I don't think we'll see them again. It's a film that will remain unique ^^
Great world building
Beautiful film
Great and weighty action, never felt like cgi models punching each other
A mostly good cast of characters albeit some aren’t as fleshed out so they kinda don’t land as well
Where it failed was that the script wasn’t as interesting as everything else.
I personally think it’s one of the greatest achievements in the MCU simply because they were able to make what is clearly the fringe of Marvel Comics lore and presented it tastefully without compromise. I’m not sure I would put it in my top ten (CAWS, Avengers, GotG, Infinity War, Civil War, IM2, MoM, Ragnarok, CAFA, Thunderbolts atmito) but it’s definitely somewhere in the top 20.
The celestial quandary was great, but also not realized very well. Seems as if they were trying to tell an A and B story and not going whole heart into either one of them.
I was so excited for the release and wanted to love but, while I don’t hate it by a long shot, it certainly fell very short for me.
The emergence revelation gave me a little clarity on him. Or maybe it’s more so headcanon who knows but im gonna elaborate anyway. Now with Eros being revealed & him having the connection with thanos we know he is an eternal as well like in the comics. In Infinity war the Titans were treated like a normal race that just overpopulated the planet & died off. When that should be impossible considering they are eternals lol.
Figuring out all life is pretty much fuel & that once life reaches a certain point a celestial will be born. & how deviants were created for their apex predator purpose & deferred from it. Killing ALL life instead of major predators, so the eternals were created to foster said “fuel” so that more celestials can be made & that ensures the survival of the universe.
thanos being an eternal in the mcu but with that deviant disorder like in the comics.. Maybe he couldve figured this out & it caused an existential crisis where his two natures are clashing. So he comes up with fair genocide, & his people deem him mad? Ever since i watched the film it had me putting 2 & 2 together & theory crafting lol. Sorry for the rant but im on to something! They just have to come out & say it!
Deviant: Whatever game you're playing, it won't work. You can't defeat me.
Ikaris: , No I know... But he can.
[gestures behind him]
Ikaris: [Tiamut appears in his true form, wielding his flaming sword]
Tiamut: Tremble before me Earth, for I am your reckoning!
Look at Hulk 2003? Was it different? Yes. Was it well-received? No.
First, it was a gorgeous movie. Any screenshot could be framed and put on a wall.
What affected me (as a painfully shy woman) was the depiction of a gentle hero. Someone who is kind, maybe a little less “loud”, but somehow saves the day through her gentleness. In so many movies with Powerful Women (tm), it seems like they just take a stoic, snarky dude, stick some boobs on them, and call it representation. Sersi *actually* felt like representation (not that “being alike” is at all required for a good story).
The movie would have made a better trilogy and split up the team a bit so we could live with the characters a little more. It had potential. I don’t agree with the amount of hate it gets though (but everyone is entitled to their own taste and opinion).
As someone who loves the film, *Suffragette*, I cannot tell you how much It moved me when I heard Black Widow say the line, "You get to make your own choices now". That one went straight to my *bones*!
As great as that moment is, though, we still haven't gotten a story that believes in itself enough to just be *about* a badass woman. We get a lot of decent social commentary here and there, but almost never a singular, introspective look into how a woman internalizes her experience in this world.
I think I'm rambling; and quite possibly doing so on a subject I have no place speaking upon. Nevertheless, I feel like Marvel keeps shooting itself in the foot when it comes to the ladies.
They're not doubling down. They're just like, "Well, we tried, but people didn't connect with it, so we're just going back to the safe bets". For me, it's especially infuriating, because I really thought they were onto something with *She-Hulk*.
I’m starting to believe that a lot people can see or comprehend beyond their brains 🧠
Brains can be an unreliable narrator
I don’t get how people can’t seem to understand that films (art) can be objectively good
Liking it or not is the subjective part
Plenty of films I can concede are well made, good films by the standards of the art form, I just don’t like them.
Though I understand why some may not prefer it? It's a bit more "refined" than some other MCU stuff and there are some people who don't like that. These people probably don't like A24 horror films either.
It was a cool concept that had some really neat stuff going on
Plus, everything with the Celestials showed them as impressive and crazy powerful as they should. For once the MCU didn't go with a more grounded take. I definitely appreciated that.
I thought it was aids
Characters were all really well done. Awesome to see the Stark boys reunite.
My idea would be for during the whole X-Men saga they’re seemingly planning for after Secret Wars, to adapt parts of the A.X.E.: Judgment Day comics event in which mutants are seen as an ‘excess deviation’ and the Eternals’ programming forces them to try eradicate the mutants leading to a conflict with the X-Men. Sersi is able to work with the Avengers to get them to intervene and help fix the issue (and then shenanigans ensue).
So yeah I think if they brought the Eternals back by saying the celestials reprogrammed them to always stick to their core directive and while losing sole of their free will and send them back to earth as an antagonistic threat to the X-Men (and also an exercise in power scaling as the X-Men will have to combat these OP characters) it could be a good way to reintroduce them while somewhat sidestepping the seemingly failed Eternals 2 plans. And have at least Sersi make it onto an Avengers team and rekindle her Jon Snow stuff with him being all “I searched for you for years” or something I dunno. And then emancipate the Eternals from their re-programming etc.
There’s also all this talk of post-Secret Wars bringing back legacy characters like Cap and Stark and even recasting them etc., so in that same spirit I think they could easily and successfully do another Eternals film that adapts Kieron Gillen’s Eternals run with a returned Thanos who schemes his way into being their ruler. So they can frame it as a Thanos film while still being about the Eternals and their struggles as Thanos tries to have control over them for his own ends. It could also then explore Thanos’ history and connection to the Eternals, him being half one himself, and what it means for the Eternals that they helped create such a creature. I still think it was a missed opportunity to not have the original Eternals film explore the connection to Thanos that the Eternals and Thea has, mostly because it would’ve made the film feel more relevant to casual audiences
Anyway did a full essay but unfortunately don’t think there’s a future for the Eternals in the MCU (even though they should at least bring back Sersi and will be a massive shame if they don’t). But I think there’s enough compelling material that they could make a full trilogy and if they play the right cards it could still be successful with general audiences, via a second one being a conflict with the X-Men, and a third a conflict with a rebooted Thanos in their system while exploring their dark history together