Just finished iron heart and… (spoilers)
I’m gonna make this short and simple. The show is great from start to end (ish). But that ending wtf. I get it, it’s in her character to make that choice but like bro. All of that just to end up a puppet for mephisto. I’m not gonna be that person who down plays the show bc it’s a female lead actress, I could care less who’s the main lead what their race or gender is so long as the story and action is good. This show achieved that up until the very end like common. I would dare say this is one of the best marvel Disney + shows if the ending didn’t exist.
What do y’all think?
What do y’all think?
Commentaires
I understand the other end of the stick for this one but the reason I enjoyed it is because it’s not how you expected the ending to play out at all.
In seriousness though I suspect she didn’t really believe Mephisto could do that. I think the reality hit her when Natalie appeared at the end.
Yeah she idolized stark and the whole “stark learns from his mistakes” is famous with him but she does not incorporate that at all. Every mistake I don’t think she’s taking and learned from if I’m being honest. Which is fine bc I don’t expect her to be like stark but if you’re a tech genius you should perhaps learn from your mistakes…
I think her mistakes are all going to compound and bring her entire world fully crashing down around her. Ironheart's origin story isn't complete and I think will be a multi-project story, just like Spider-Man was with the trilogy.
I hope we see more, but you might be right. If anything she'll probably be a background character and have her story resolved quickly, unfortunately.
I think if Marvel ever wants to experiment with another actor playing Tony Stark, they should give us a short series about his youth. I have a feeling SHIELD never really let Tony out of sight. I'm also okay with comics and the MCU doing their own remixes.
There are multiple instances in the MCU alone where a character's growth happens over the course of a couple days to a week or two.
Like, according to the Official Marvel timeline, all of Iron Man 2 takes place over 3 weeks and most of it is the gap between the Senate hearing to the Monaco attack. Everything from the Monaco attack to the finale was 8 days. It was 2 days between Stark & Rhodie fighting in the mansion to the Stark Expo. Over 2 days, Tony goes from a suicidal alcoholic willing to throw hands with his best friend to being put on house arrest to creating a new arc reactor design to being pulled out of his funk.
It's also the plot for his character in IM1 and Avengers and IM3 and AoU and Civil War and Endgame. He has the same character arc over and over like no one watched the previous film they're making a sequel to. His growth is often overstated by fans for reasons I don't fully comprehend.
On the other hand, Riri doesn't have any real consequences to invite her to learn from her mistakes because they haven't become obvious mistakes yet. In the end she gets basically everything she wanted by literally magic. Difficult to find motivation for change when all of your misdeeds are rewarded.
As for Riri, she may be on a negative character arc (that was intended to be explored more in a Season 2 that may not happen now), or even a flat one. There's more options to writing characters than just positive character arcs.
Riri started "good" but over the episodes we see her make questionable choices like leaving someone to die & creating that AI. Her deal with Mephisto confirms she's pretty messed up.
At least that's my interpretation for now, assuming they'll continue her story as Mephisto's pawn. I expect she'll at least be a secondary villain at some point given how hungry she is to be "iconic" then maybe get a redemption arc in the end.
Closest she got to be involved with Mephisto in the comics was when she got possesed by Blackheart who is his son, but she never made a deal with either of them as in the show
Now there is always the chances they could change this for brand synergy since Marvel always loves to make sure the characters in page reflect their MCU counterparts.
She makes the suit to just prove she can, she joins a criminal organisation for money and she's pretty arrogant. That's fine, she can have a character arc. But it never comes.
She uses dark magic without thinking of the reprocutions, she only goes after the Hood for selfish reasons and she makes a deal with the devil. She never even becomes likable. Iron Man was also an asshole but he was funny and there's multiple scenes showing him save lives.
The actual hero of the story is Joe. He helps Iron Heart, wants to help the world, gets locked up because he helped Iron Heart, gets his revenge, refuses to kill her and then gets controlled by the bad guy.
Edit: I'm not a fan of open endings for series that most likely won't get second seasons. I hope it gets a season 2 because I think that'd help me like season 1 more.
She didn't really have one to begin with. She was morally grey from the start and only interested in her own safety & aspirations.
I would be fine with her being a villain if it was pulled off in a an interesting way, but it wasn't. It felt rushed and not very satisfying.
Edit: very rich of someone who wasn't even involved to jump in, complain about respect while lobbing insults, and then immediately block me
If we're talking about the results of that last decision, the audience can take one of two paths. Either we assume it goes about as well as it did for Mephisto's other business partners (we saw what happened with the hood, so we know it likely won't end well) or we assume season 2 will (or... would have...) showcase Riri clumsily getting out of the deal.
One of the definitions of villain is: "The person or thing responsible for specified problems, harm, or damage.".
Riri is the reason she got expelled, Riri joined a criminal gang willingly, Riri neglected to take care of Joe's tech and got him arrested, Riri used black magic that got her AI friend erased, Riri made a deal with Mephisto and now works for him.
She also hasn't done a single heroic act. Every one of her actions was either to help herself or fix a mistake she made.
I think this makes her somewhat of a villain, not a major one though.
This all could've been more interesting for me personally if they expanded on the ending. Or who knows, maybe it'll get a season 2.
Edit: The hoods friend did try to kill her so what she did was self defense. Everything else was on her though.
The one that was actively trying to kill her in that scene?
And sure, not everyone would do it, but lots would. You think people really give a damn about their "souls"
And yes hella ppl don’t care about their soul but you also have ppl who does
Wanda has done FAR worse things, and people aren't making 30 min videos about how "terrible" the character is
It suited the character in every way:
Unable to part from her best friend and resist getting her back
Making headstrong decisions
Thinking she can one-up someone (thing?) like Mephisto and have the best of both worlds (very Tony-esque)
Emotional decision
Equally, imagine starting out Mephisto in the MCU and the first thing he does is fail to use his cunning and malice to trick Ironheart. That would be atrocious
Man I really hope we can revisit Ironheart (and Mephisto) instead of these characters being ignored (or completely rebooted after Secret Wars)
I just hope there are long term consequences that play out from this decision.
She never becomes a hero and she just constantly makes bad, questionable and selfish decisions until the end. She has no character development like Iron Man did and she never redeems herself
Maybe she gets this arc in season 2 or whatever role was going to be in Armor Wars
I don’t get the people who are so against her making an obvious decision for her character. Every episode was better than the one that came before. I’m very glad I watched it.
So you do care a little?
For all the glazing Iron Man gets, they never showed you the double dealing and screw jobs he handed out to people on his way to the top.
It was only when he got hit with his own missile that he wisened up, much like how we hopefully see Riri handle the pitfalls she's about to go through
The only thing I didn't like about the ending was the weird fake-out editing.
Everyone overcoming everything in the final act is a repetitive and boring story.
My real issue with this character is it seems like they have no future plans for her. Much of the MCU in the 2020s feels rudderless and unfocused.
I thought it was good to get her making a pretty terrible decision, she feels very real for it. I'd make a bad choice for a lot less.
The entire show we get the idea Riri is in a dark place and still not over what has happened, it doesn’t seem out of character that in a time of desperation she’d take the deal.
It would’ve been much worse if throughout the show we watched Riri healing only to suddenly switch in the final moments
Iron Man 1: When given the choice of building a missile for terrorists or be killed, Stark chooses Door 3 by secretly building the Mk1 suit to escape.
Thor 1: When the Destroyer comes to town, Thor has the option to fight with his friends at the risk of their lives or offer himself as a sacrifice to appease Loki. He lucked into Door 3 by becoming worthy of Mjolnir and his Asgardian strength when he would have otherwise died.
Captain America 1: Either fly himself into the ice to drown Red Skull's warplane or risk the mega bombs deploying while working on a solution that wouldn't involve his own death. Like Thor, he lucked into Door 3 in that the serum allowed him to survive in ice until he was eventually found.
Avengers: Iron Man redirecting the nuke into the portal was supposed to be a one-way trip, but the other option was to allow it to level New York. Once again, the hero lucked into Door 3 when he fell out of the portal before it closed.
Following this trend (which is common among the genre as a total, not just the MCU), Riri was faced with a choice early on to join the criminal gang or find a legitimate source of funding. She took the objectively worse choice thinking that she could walk away clean by making sure no one got hurt during the heists (making her own luck, kinda of like Stark in IM1).
She does not take magical threats seriously, no doubt believing in the strength of her science just like Tony Stark. Riri downplayed how seriously she takes Mephisto when she called him "Mr. Dormamu Man" even though she was explicitly told earlier that Dormammu has apocalyptic powers and owns his own friggin' dimension. And yet the guy she choose to work directly with someone who basically claimed to outscale Dormammu. Riri already thinks Door 2 isn't a big downside (despite leaving Parker like an addict in withdrawls) and is sure she'll find or create Door 3 so that she gets everything she wants (including her dead friend being brought back to life) and suffer no meaningful consequences.
She had plenty of chances to turn away but chose not too bc of her pride
I disagree that she took Mephisto's deal out of pride. It was a mixture of desperation and arrogance. She wanted her friend back and thinks she can get out from under his thumb. All wins for her and losses for him. That's her "plan."
The rest of the show however, it was a struggle to get through, the dialogue, the supporting characters, the double-standards... it was bad.