Secret Invasion events have no consequences in The Marvels?

I’m watching the MCU for the first time, and I saw first SI and now I’m watching The Marvels, but I have a lot of doubts: Captain Marvel found a place for the Skrulls and that was Tarnax? But Talos said in SI that he called all the Skrulls in the space? Please I need all the Skrull’s story and background. And also, where does Val bring all the Skrulls in The Marvels??

Voir le contenu lié

Commentaires

eagc72025-12-06 05:29

They actually do address the Skrull planet from The Marvel's in SI, as Talos says that the only ones that refused to join them in Earth was Emperor Dro'ge's colony (the colony being what we saw in The Marvels).

The question is more why didn't Talos and the other Skrulls join Dro'ge's on the planet they took residence (unless the planet couldn't contain all of the Skrulls or something), now i think its possible that Dro'ge and his Skrulls took residence there without any help from Carol Danvers

Pitiful_Life25022025-12-06 05:31

Thanks I didn’t connect that Tarnax was that colony’s Talos was talking about

Peslian2025-12-06 06:19

That is also addressed in SI, they wanted somewhere that the Kree didn't know about and away from the gate network.

Edit: Considering what happened to the Emperor's colony in The Marvels seems like a valid concern.

ToxethOGrady2025-12-06 05:36

It'll be retconned away or just quietly forgotten

eagc72025-12-06 05:38

Funny thing is that SI, the same show that says Skrulls has no planet to take residence on was the first to confirm the existence of the Skrull planet from The Marvels

RusticusB2025-12-06 05:38

Just ignore that it exists. The MCU definitely did and will probably continue to do so going forward lol

Kind-Spot49052025-12-06 05:43

I’m looking forward to the return of Maria Hill.

RusticusB2025-12-06 05:46

I truly think they can just put her in Doomsday without any explanation and it will be perfectly fine. Everyone will follow along and just treat it like a whoopsie like a few of the actors playing different roles or the Spiderman Homecoming timejump screw up. The everyday audience does not give a fuck and even the diehard MCU audience seems to be okay with ignoring Secret Invasion lol

InnocentTailor2025-12-06 06:03

The universe is getting rebooted anyways, so her death can be easily retconned.

ThomasEdison44442025-12-06 06:29

Its like a reverse Poochie from the Simpsons.

She was revived on her way back to her home universe.

Or better yet, retcon and make her part Asgardian and she went to Valhalla 🤷🏽‍♂️

RusticusB2025-12-06 06:34

*What happened here? Lightning hit the transmitter?*

eriverside2025-12-06 10:34

Bro, the MCU itself is ok with ignoring SI.

The end of si is a global civil war with people killing each other , accusing them of being Skrulls. This is not addressed in anything that came after. Not Marvels, not brave new world (when Ross is specifically talking about what people are scared of right now), not thunderbolts.

thecockmeister2025-12-06 17:31

Took years for a literal giant marble baby that hatched from the Earth to be remembered. Doubt this would be any different.

eriverside2025-12-06 17:46

I think they would have ignored it too but decided to use it to introduce adamantium

GreenWoodDragon2025-12-06 17:01

I didn't even know who Maria Hill was but after a few minutes of screen time felt bitterly disappointed at her demise.

DoubleStrength2025-12-06 08:58

The fact that Life Model Decoys have never once been used as a narrative device in th MCU films to avoid killing people off is a travesty.

(Apparently they were used in Agents of SHIELD? But I haven't seen it.)

Fury got himself blown up (Winter Soldier), Hill got jobbed (SI) and NEITHER of them - the two highest ranking SHIELD officers - had a LMD on standby.

eagc72025-12-06 20:36

Yeah SHIELD made use of them, they even used it on the final season as a way to bring Coulson back after he died for a second time in the show itself

CharacterOld86912025-12-06 13:25

She would have been good to bring back in Loki season 2.

chargernj2025-12-06 19:08

Maria Hill was in deep space performing a secret mission for S.W.O.R.D. A Skrull S.W.O.R.D. agent replaced her on Earth. The Skrull is who we saw die. Fury never corrected the record because Hill was even more protected when everyone thinks she is already dead.

No-Today-24592025-12-06 05:53

the only thing that remains from secret invasion is earthlings know about skrulls hiding on earth

RusticusB2025-12-06 05:57

Eh there’s wizards, aliens, gods, werewolves, swamp things that are fairly common knowledge, at this point I doubt the earthlings would even care about Skrulls lol. “Are they gonna wipe out half of life or whatever? No? Who cares.”

No-Today-24592025-12-06 11:45

they know they exist but don't seem to care much. matt murdoch's client in born again asks if he could argue that it was a skrull impersonating him as his defense.

eriverside2025-12-06 10:30

Are you sure? It's not mentioned in anything else as far as I can remember.

During the opening scene of brave new world, president Ross doesn't mention the alien civil war.

No-Today-24592025-12-06 11:44

matt murdoch's client in born again asks if he could argue that it was a skrull impersonating him as his defense

eriverside2025-12-06 13:13

But that's after Marvels. Could be from that event, or revelations of Captain Marvel after Infinity war - I assume people knew about the skrulls when they found out Captain Marvel is off world helping aliens.

No-Today-24592025-12-06 16:27

I just mean that seems to be the only real consequence for the MCU earth after secret invasion. I don’t see how they would know about Skrulls secretly living on earth passing as humans any other way.

ThomasEdison44442025-12-06 06:28

This is the way.

I constantly point to Secret Invasion as the lowest of the low MCU point.

snowe992025-12-06 20:37

I actually have a vision of a future Disney conference where Feige comes out and announces the usual new slate, and as he’s giving updates on of the things he says is “We heard you, we are going to de-canonize ‘Secret Invasion’” and the crowd gives a thunderous applause

Spoked4512025-12-06 06:27

Didn't happen in 616,so just a stand alone story or maybe a "what if?"

Meizas2025-12-06 08:15

They could still do this. It'd be a super easy retcon.

HawkeyeGild2025-12-06 06:32

Not aware if secret invasion, I do t think that is MCU

DJfunkyPuddle2025-12-06 07:24

Best to consider SI happening in another universe and move on.

Meizas2025-12-06 08:13

Secret Invasion has had literally no impact on anything and they need to just say it was in another universe. We even forgot Gavin was the president and just suddenly had Thunderbolt Ross as president instead.

DoubleStrength2025-12-06 09:05

>We even forgot ***Ritson** was the president and just suddenly had Thunderbolt Ross as president instead.

Nah, that made a little sense.

Ritson attempted to declare ALL aliens as hostile occupants of Earth... Technically that included the likes of Thor and all his Asgardian buddies.

It could easily be waved off as being an unpopular move that quickly got reversed and lost Ritson the presidency (to Ross) at the next election.

eriverside2025-12-06 10:42

The end of SI has people killing each other in the streets because they may or may not be skrulls.

Beginning of brave new world , Ross is campaigning or just became president and his speech is about the things that people are scared of right now and neither aliens among us or rampant violence are one of them. To me, that was MCUs signal to ignore all of SI.

Meizas2025-12-06 16:23

Pretty sure his name is either Gavin or Russell 😉

And that action + people killing each other and the prime minister dying had NO ramifications that were ever mentioned again? But also, he should have gotten a mention in Thunderbolts when Val said something about president Ross. Should've said something like, "Our last president turned into a big red rage monster, and the one before him started a war with space" or something.

mercy_death2025-12-06 10:49

Literally none. Especially as its shown in FFH and WandaVision that Fury is already in space. Its also WILD that Carol asks Valkyrie to host them on earth directly after the reveal of the skrull invasion.

That show was made for the hell of it.

eagc72025-12-06 20:34

I would feel the Skrulls are more safe with the Asgardians on New Asgard, anyone wanting to pick a fight with Asgard must have a death-wish

ScottishExile2025-12-06 16:12

Secret Invasion died on the way back to its home planet.

N8CCRG2025-12-06 16:17

Val presumably brings all the Skrulls to New Asgard, which is already a refuge of a mix of aliens from both Sakaar and (old) Asgard.

I was originally really hoping that this, in combination with President Ritson's war against all aliens, was going to be a more important plot point in a follow-up like Brave New World, but it seems they just ignored it and wrote it off instead.

mega5122025-12-06 18:04

Secret Invasion will be ignored. It was a disaster.

santa99912025-12-06 20:00

I’ll truly never understand why they didn’t tie these projects together.

Secret invasion show being about Fury and a team (say hill, Ross, maybe introduce someone cool like Jessica Drew) investigating this situation. Slowly revealing more and more people have been taken. End It with a tease of the Super Skrull

Then Captain marvel 2 being Carol, Monica, and Kamala (she’s brought in cause the skrulls wouldn’t know about her) fighting the super skrull and trying to end the invasion

Would allow them to have the “spy thriller” they were going for without doing too much. Would give Carol a solid 2nd story, her dealing with the consequences of avoiding her past, etc.

Then you go make the 3rd movie for Carol being her vs the Kree wanting revenge

Bivolion132025-12-08 01:06

What Secret Invasion events? I don't think they've adapted that yet.

MarcSpector17012025-12-08 15:14

The Skrulls are a space-faring species. Why can't they find their own frigging planet? Humans don't even have spaceships yet.

Marvel probably thought they were being edgy and clever portraying the Skrulls as good guy refugees but it ruined the Skrulls and it ruined Secret Invasion too.

LooseSeal882025-12-08 17:38

I still don't even know which of those two projects is supposed to take place first chronologically. I know Secret Invasion released first and Talos is missing from it, but on the other hand, Nick Fury is still living in space for The Marvels and has a cheery disposition, so I always assumed The Marvels was first in the timeline.