How did Strange view millions of possible futures if they are on the sacred timeline?

If there is a sacred timeline that has been pre-written, then how did Doctor Strange view millions of potential futures in Infinity War? Did Kang just give him visions of futures that weren’t actually real so that he’d do the thing that was supposed to happen on the Sacred Timeline?

Voir le contenu lié

Commentaires

swagonflyyyy2025-12-01 20:30

They could've been branching timelines that did not breach the Sacred Timeline.

dbkenny4262025-12-01 20:31

He projected himself into the future to see what results various actions would have. He wasn't viewing alternate realities, just their own under different circumstances.

Caciulacdlac2025-12-01 20:31

His visions are simulations, they're not actually real futures. Also, if they end up being pruned, wouldn't that count as a loss?

GullibleGap99662025-12-02 00:50

Well we are going by Strange's personal opinion on the matter but I think he would consider that a loss.

Void_Warden2025-12-01 20:32

1.As stated in the Loki show, the "Sacred Timeline" isn't a single timeline. It's a collection of timelines which don't deviate too much from HWR's script.

2. Since the TVA is actively "cropping" timelines, the possible futures still remain possible. It's just that most of them don't become real because they're "cropped" before they get the chance to grow. Like a tree still has the potential to grow, whether or not you'll cut it in the near future.

Far_Combination76392025-12-01 21:44

> the "Sacred Timeline" isn't a single timeline

When do they say this? That’s not how a timeline works. Lines don’t have branches. That’s just geometry.

Void_Warden2025-12-01 21:53

Thinking basic geometry applies to fictional time shenanigans is strange. Even stranger is thinking timeline and line are somehow synonymous.

But, to your points. The timeline is shown to be a collection of realities in most visual representations of the sacred timeline. For example, look at the screens and the "red lines" delimiting the acceptable limits of variation.
It's also confirmed [here](https://screencrush.com/michael-waldron-interview-loki-heels/).

Additionally, HWR pretty much confirms that even the "pruned" timelines had to be allowed to exist up until a certain point since he needed both Variant Loki and Sylvie to exist

GullibleGap99662025-12-02 00:55

I think they mentioned that line isn't a great model for a timeline but they use it to help them make plans anyway. The visualizations on screen shouldnt be taken too literally

GullibleGap99662025-12-02 00:53

They mentioned in Loki that a line on the screen isnt a particularly accurate model but they use it because they dont know of a better way to make a simple diagram on a screen.

swagonflyyyy2025-12-11 08:16

But like, the time loom literally visualizes this tho...

GullibleGap99662025-12-11 14:33

Good catch, but they still said it briefly at the tva

prettyyoungpeso2025-12-01 20:33

The ending of Loki S1 spells this out very clearly. Once HWR died, his actions were cosmically retconned, making so the multiverse ALWAYS existed. And since the only alternative to HWR creating the sacred timeline was Loki holding up the multiverse, the multiverse always existed, because time is circular not linear in the MCU.

So in simple terms, the sacred timeline never existed and the multiverse always has

simward2025-12-01 20:45

What you're saying is true but also it doesn't answer OP's question. Strange could see possible futures because he was just "simulating" outcome.

prettyyoungpeso2025-12-02 23:50

I mean sure but that goes against the canon of the MCU and isn’t really backed by evidence. Endgame is the first MCU project to portray the multiverse via the time heist, and those branches are just a few of the endless ones that already existed during Infinity War because of the circular nature of time and God Loki always having been holding up the branches.

So when Thanos killed 616 Loki, God Loki was holding the branch of the universe in which that happened.

pje11282025-12-01 20:36

It's possible he saw a lot of those timelines get pruned and that's one of the reasons he could only the 1 win.

Or the time stone only shows possible futures without multiversal intervention, and he was saying timelines as they would have played out had the TVA not pruned them.

jfcat2002025-12-01 20:37

The sacred timeline is the one Strange chose. That's why it's the sacred timeline. I'm not saying it's because of Strange. I'm saying that because it is the sacred timeline is why Strange chose it. In effect Strange had no choice because if he had chosen differently then that's not the sacred timeline. It's circular logic cause and effect. It is because it is.

eagc72025-12-01 20:38

Because that's what He Who Remains wanted to happen, he wanted Strange to see potential scenarios that he already decided weren't gonna happen and if they did well... prune time

AKluthe2025-12-01 20:40

I don't think they've really clarified the time stone's exact abilities or the extent of its power.

I think the idea at the time of Infinity War was Strange really does preview a bunch of futures and the only one that succeeds is the way it plays out.

Later Loki S1 adds to the lore with the idea the TVA maintains the MCU's series of events on one sacred timeline. And that universes in the multiverse branch when decisions are made.

GullibleGap99662025-12-02 00:57

Yes time magic doesn't hold up under heavy real world scrutiny. The time stone is a plot device not meant to be fully understood.

PixelPeach1232025-12-01 20:46

Eh.. wibbly-wobbly, and what not

sabrinavd2025-12-01 21:01

how doctor who did all of this without creating chaos from the beginning?

lontrinium2025-12-01 21:18

It's only not sacred if the TVA show up to delete it.

moonshadow502025-12-01 21:30

The "Sacred Timeline" was just propaganda for "He Who Remains" Kang wanting to prevent any other Kangs. It is not a single "sacred timeline".

There were infinite timeliness that still existed, or could exist, unless they had a point that could branch to Kang.

How could these timelines have existed up to the point of having: Sylvie, Alligator Loki, Frog Thor etc. all live part of their lives, without being pruned the moment their existence was possible?

There's a very in-world possibility, that Strange saw 14 million timelines none of which led to a Kang-branch, or at least didn't lead to a Kang-branch in the time it took to see Thanos win.

Petrichor022025-12-01 22:22

In the MCU, all possible futures exist as abstract time. We were told in the Loki show that the Temporal Loom takes abstract time and turns it into a series of physical timelines that the TVA and Kang can then monitor and affect. The physical timelines that played out the way Kang wanted history to go (minus Loki's branch timeline) were called the "Sacred Timeline".

So Strange was viewing the various timelines that existed as abstract time, that would become physical timelines that the TVA would destroy, or that would become physical timelines that were part of the Sacred Timeline among the millions of possible futures he viewed.

AmericanUpheaval3572025-12-01 22:51

Loki

spidervenom6192025-12-01 23:47

1. The "Sacred Timeline" is just TVA propaganda, nothing more and nothing else. I really wished people stop using He Who Remains words a Gospel cause at the end of the day he still Kang.

2. Strange only look through timelines that was on Titan on the moment and can't look past his death (Let's just ignore the fact that Strange's is getting dusting which means that's should also count as a death as well) For some odd reason that I swear has to be based on a Kang, all of the other timelines are considered Losses by him in some way against Thanos (Let's just ignore the fact that bunch of them involves Thanos losing his head or dying by Wanda or Tony or Odinson or whoever)).

labbla2025-12-02 01:29

The Sacred Timeline wasn't a thing when infinity War was made.

juances192025-12-02 01:48

The stone can only look at the timeline of the universe it's currently in, it cannot know if beings from outside of that universe will show up, they are outside of it's reach.

So the TVA or any other multiverse hoping being are like blindspots, they'll never show up on visions of the future.

TylerHyena2025-12-02 02:11

But you said it in the OP, those are only potential futures and possibilities, not the ones that actually take place and since those futures didn’t happen there’s no reason for the TVA to intervene.