Hulk-Thanos problem
How would you guys feel if instead of the opening scene we got in infinity war we got this: It’s still the same shot of the broken up asgardian ship but your hearing super sonic booms. They show thor and heimdall down. They show Loki and thanos minions patiently waiting. Loki is nervous he knows he cannot fight thanos he tried a little bit but he is smart enough to wait.
Then we seen thanos and hulk fighting and it is reveal that they have been fighting for hours or days. Thanos is tired but looks confident, hulks is trying to stay angry but he is starting to get tired. Finally beats him, heimdall sends him away, Loki pretends to be on thanos side and still attacks and dies the same way.
I feel like this would make more sense, even if it is off screen it would give hulk his fair shake, we could even see hulk getting in a few good punches. It would still show how strong thanos is without nerfing hulk. And in the original scene it didn’t make sense to me why hulk was hiding until Loki said “we have a hulk”. So it would make more sense to me.
Then we seen thanos and hulk fighting and it is reveal that they have been fighting for hours or days. Thanos is tired but looks confident, hulks is trying to stay angry but he is starting to get tired. Finally beats him, heimdall sends him away, Loki pretends to be on thanos side and still attacks and dies the same way.
I feel like this would make more sense, even if it is off screen it would give hulk his fair shake, we could even see hulk getting in a few good punches. It would still show how strong thanos is without nerfing hulk. And in the original scene it didn’t make sense to me why hulk was hiding until Loki said “we have a hulk”. So it would make more sense to me.
Commentaires
That’s way too long a fight and would instantly kill Thanos’ aura as a threat.
Thanos is the only Phase 1 introduced character that WASN'T only chosen because they lacked the rights to their more popular characters. He was always meant to be. He was..... *inevitable* if you will. Because he is Marvel's ultimate villain. Marvel's equivalent to Darkseid. Whenever he shows up it's REALLY bad news and it often takes multiple heroes to defeat him. (Thor also regularly jobs to him.) He even beat Galactus once by outsmarting him.
Why do you think the final boss of the MCU should have been shown getting worn out in his proper introduction? That doesn't set the mood for a film where the heroes not only lost, *but suffered the most horrific loss imaginable.*
The movies were pretty great after 10years of build-up, and we will probably never see anything like it ever again.
Pack it up boys, looks like youre not allowed to answer questions anymore.
Thanos should never lose to Hulk. Ever. It makes no sense. Even if Hulk is stronger.
Thanos knows how to fight
I do agree that MCU should've shown more Hulk mash scenes but cos of Universal situation they used him as side character. I don't know if they can make a Hulk movie without including Hulk name in the title.
Skip Maws, Lokis, and Thanos talking, all together.
If it was meant to set the tone that the two most powerful avengers got taken out by thanos, SHOW US.
I would have been completely fine with what happend still happens if they showed us thanos blowing up the asgarian ship, and them being beaten.
The first 20 mins should have been Chaos, of thor trying to get people out and safe again. The ship being under fire and broaded,
It should have been a small glimspe of what he did to Xandar. But worse now since he has the stone.
Show us hulk and thor fighting hoard off with korg, meek, and Valkyrie.
And them being over run, and then have the fight thanos childern
and hulk having to fight in a Fragile ship trying not to break it.
Have thor and hulk hold off the childern and the hoard while Valk, Korg and meek leave with the Civilians.
And then give us the the same scene
You could do that instead, show that Thanos couldn't win on his own and resorted to the Stone (kinda like it ends up in Endgame against Captain Marvel). But a fight that drags for hours/days would be silly in this context unless you reorder things around and make Thanos board the ship before going to Xandar.