Accurate Captain America shield replica

I wanna get a good Captain America Shield Replica but my main issue is that the colour looks too metallicy and painted on almost looks toy ish when I’ve looked online

And yes before anyone asks I’ve checked online on Etsy and Amazon etc

If anyone knows any propmakers that make good cap shields lmk my budget is 350$ I wanna get it close to the colour in this image

Commentaires

unsupported2025-11-25 16:17

The other main issue is making a shield that doesn't obey the laws of physics at all!

Valentinee1052025-11-25 16:23

Something something vibranium.

steve652832025-11-25 16:22

Disney sells an official metal one with the carrying case from Endgame for like $400 on their website. The only inaccurate thing is the box on the back for sounds. I have the cracked one and love it

Golbeza2025-11-25 16:25

https://www.disneystore.com/captain-america-vibranium-shield-with-carrying-case-461063517964.html this is the one i have in my man cave but it’s currently sold out, if you check eBay there should be resellers.

brandogg3602025-11-25 16:31

The part in the middle where the star pieces don't align correctly is really triggering

Boil-san2025-11-26 04:49

The part at the end where you say reapply rather than really is, well, really triggering... ;\^p

TopBee832025-11-25 16:46

I’d honestly look on Etsy for something. I just found some nice 30” shields for half the budget you’re proposing.

Also you could try to find a blank shield and paint it yourself, they seem a lot harder to find than even just a year ago when I looked but that what I’d do

orange7slices2025-11-26 00:40

Check out ComicSandwiches

Upper-Mammoth-91512025-11-26 04:42

Lots of vendors at Etsy have them for sale (Black Friday) for $120 to $200. Take a look. The pics look amazing.

Boil-san2025-11-26 04:47

Gonna need to source some vibranium if you want it to be accurate...! ;\^p

coussens52025-11-26 05:18

I've cosplayed as Cap for years and I volunteer for local events and hospitals. In my research overtime, I think the best bang for your buck at your price range will be a marvel 75th anniversary edition from ebay. They're likely reproductions of the Hasbro metal shield run but they're pretty legit. After that, its Comic Sandwiches which come in around $600 then its like Newman Assembles or another custom maker but those are at or above $1k usually. Newman also just announced he's raising his prices next year so look into those and decide quick!

In the photos below. There's a picture I included of two shields. You'll notice right away the difference. Most of the shields around the $100 price range usually have "steps" down as you move out from the center. This is a feature that ALWAYS bugged me and I have bought over 5 shields trying to find the right one for me. I've just also bought this one https://ebay.us/m/zi1q8E today but we will see how it goes, from the pictures, it looks great, but I've been misled at this price before!

- My main shield: https://ebay.us/m/OHPBry

- Photos of it: https://imgur.com/a/nmg0bG5

LordCurlyy2025-11-26 09:12

Thank you so much bro🫶, this is the one of the few comments that helped me (also your cosplay looks incredible^^)

coussens52025-11-26 15:03

Thanks and happy to help! If you ever wonder about if a shield is legit, just ask the seller for more photos. I've actually gotten a shield refunded by ebay before because the seller lied about the style. That shield is now pink for breast cancer walks haha.

Owen93032025-11-26 06:30

I’ve been looking for one for the better part of 10 years. I want one that’s made of metal and is as movie accurate as possible. Still no luck 10 years later but maybe one day.

LordCurlyy2025-11-26 09:14

Yeah I get you for me the colour is the main issue like it doesn’t have that look that makes the paint look like apart of the metal but hopefully we will find our shields one day 🤘🏻

blu-tron2025-11-26 06:31

Comic sandwiches

FluxChiller2025-11-26 06:41

pSStttt.... you want to check out the [replica prop forum](https://www.therpf.com/forums/). If it exists, it will be there.

LordCurlyy2025-11-26 09:17

Thanks a lot will definetly check it out

String29242025-11-30 01:01

Its somewhat accurate... its not Vibranium..