All 37 MCU movies ranked based on multiple sources

I made a full list of every MCU movie ranked from best to worst. Ratings are based on Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, CinemaScore, and IMDB. Their scores are the average of their rankings from each source. Tiebreakers are determined by box office.

1. Avengers: Endgame **(1.75)**
2. Iron Man **(3.25)**
3. Spider-Man: No Way Home **(4.5)**
4. Black Panther **(4.75)**
5. Thor: Ragnarok **(4.75)**
6. Guardians of the Galaxy **(4.75)**
7. Captain America: Civil War **(6.75)**
8. The Avengers **(7.25)**
9. Spider-Man: Homecoming **(7.25)**
10. Doctor Strange **(8.75)**
11. Captain America: The Winter Soldier **(9)**
12. Avengers: Infinity War **(9.25)**
13. Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings **(9.25)**
14. Spider-Man: Far From Home **(10.25)**
15. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 **(12.5)**
16. Ant Man and the Wasp **(13)**
17. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 **(13.5)**
18. Thunderbolts\* **(13.75)**
19. Avengers: Age of Ultron **(16.25)**
20. Ant Man **(16.5)**
21. Fantastic Four: First Steps **(17)**
22. Captain America: The First Avenger **(17.5)**
23. Black Panther: Wakanda Forever **(17.75)**
24. Deadpool & Wolverine **(18)**
25. Iron Man 3 **(18.25)**
26. Black Widow **(18.25)**
27. Captain Marvel **(19.5)**
28. Thor **(20.75)**
29. Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness **(21.75)**
30. Iron Man 2 **(21.75)**
31. The Incredible Hulk **(22.75)**
32. Thor: The Dark World **(23.75)**
33. Thor: Love and Thunder **(25)**
34. Eternals **(26.5)**
35. The Marvels **(27.5)**
36. Ant Man and the Wasp: Quantamania **(27.75)**
37. Captain America: Brave New World **(28.75)**

Thoughts:

Kinda surprised how low Infinity War and Age of Ultron were. Also felt like Thunderbolts and Fantastic Four was ranked a little too high. No Way Home also surprised me at how high it was. The rest of the rankings were pretty much expected. Fun Fact: Black Panther was ranked 1st for every site but 13th for IMDB, which brought its average way down.

Voir le contenu lié

Commentaires

BatmanForever232025-11-23 23:42

You've combined a bunch of scores that mean utterly different things - so these final numbers have absolutely no value. For instance, a Rotten Tomatoes score is not comparable to an IMDb score as RT indicates a % of people who thought the project to be 'Fresh', whereas IMDb is a straight 1-10 score. Furthermore, sites like IMDb are infamous for review bombing...

FX1142025-11-23 23:44

I'm confused what the numbers assigned to each title actually mean.

BatmanForever232025-11-23 23:44

Presumably an average of all these incompatible scores.

FX1142025-11-23 23:46

But it's been normalized into lower being better?

BatmanForever232025-11-23 23:48

It'll be each movie's ranking from 1-37 on each metric, with 1 being best I think. The methodology is broken in so many ways, but at least it's consistent?

rasputin12025-11-23 23:55

it literally says the average of the ranking from each source. top place in one and 2nd place in another gives an average ranking of 1.5.

Caciulacdlac2025-11-23 23:46

IMDB rankings are irrelevant, anyone can vote there, including those who haven't seen the movie, or vote multiple times using multiple accounts, making them completely useless.

LordDusty2025-11-24 01:33

Critic ratings are also irrelevant because why should a small sample group of reviews be a good representation of overall feelings towards a movie.

Not to mention that art is entirely subjective so really no rankings, professional nor casual, should be trusted

DSGandalf2025-11-23 23:46

How come the lower value means more score? How do you reach those values?

rasputin12025-11-23 23:54

it literally says the average of the ranking from each source. top place in one and 2nd place in another gives an average ranking of 1.5.

DSGandalf2025-11-24 00:53

Ok, yeah... I misread and understand it all wrong lol

Glass-Economy68882025-11-23 23:56

Pretty sure the lower numbers mean the movie is ranked higher

If you rank them from 1 to 37.

1 means the best

37 means the worst

Prize_Instance_14162025-11-23 23:52

All I know is ant man Quantumania is dead last or the list is skewed.

Glass-Economy68882025-11-23 23:56

The list is janky

AdaptedInfiltrator2025-11-23 23:58

This is list is wack. Infinity War is unanimously a top 5 MCU movie widely considered the best. There is no way it doesn’t crack top 10

Glass-Economy68882025-11-24 00:01

I don't think Black Panther is the 4th best film in the MCU. At the same it's worlds better than Thor Ragnarok

marvelcomics222025-11-24 08:35

Brave New World is not the worst MCU movie.

StrLord_Who2025-11-25 13:14

Well I think it's definitely an interesting look at the aggregate data. Thanks for posting.

Golbeza2025-11-25 16:50

Congratulations, this is the new worst list I’ve ever seen!