← Retour à la liste

Was Thanos Right after all?

If you think about it, if you wish 3.5 billion people into a world where this doubles the population, instantly, you will have massive famine, war and possible the end of civilization. This was swept under the rug by marvel who assumes only
Minor amounts of refugees when in reality it would be hundreds of millions

Voir le contenu lié

Commentaires

juances192025-11-15 20:56

> If you think about it, if you wish 3.5 billion people into a world where this doubles the population, instantly, you will have massive famine, war and possible the end of civilization.

But that would be a problem caused by Thanos own snap. How does that make him right?

This is like someone pouring gasoline over your house, setting it on fire then later on telling you "see, your house was a fire risk after all!"

Anyways

> massive famine

Depends on Thanos' definition of "life" tbh. If cows/chicken/fish were part of the snap, then when everyone was brought back, at least our available sources of meat also doubled to accommodate.

Crops/fruits is more debatable, plants are life but the only tree we saw getting snapped was Groot. So the only ones that may starve will be the vegans.

Gorguf622025-11-15 21:02

The movie makes it clear that Earth is only as stable as it is because the Avengers are keeping order.

mikepictor2025-11-15 21:02

Downvoted for AI

SixIsNotANumber2025-11-15 21:09

Oh, look...more AI Slop.

🤮🤮🤮🤮

knotsteve2025-11-15 21:55

Someone being wrong doesn't make Thanos right.

New_Range_22672025-11-19 16:44

No, not a random person. But in this case, The Avengers being wrong does prove thanos right empirically by showing that overpopulation can destroy society

knotsteve2025-11-19 17:08

Oh gosh, such terrible logic. Even if it were proved empirically that overpopulation alone destroys societies, that doesn’t make murdering half of them a solution. Identifying a problem is completely different from identifying a solution.

Arguing that Thanos was right is just edgelord trolling.

New_Range_22672025-11-19 17:17

Well they undid what he did and it leads them dying anyway. So if bringing them back is bad, killing them first is good

knotsteve2025-11-19 17:22

We're done. This exchange is creepy.

Mods pulled your thread, but you are still engaging in arguing with people in the thread. Read the room; it's almost empty.