The film when released had a mixed to negative ratings what are your current thoughts on the film ?
Commentaires
CaleBoi252025-11-08 18:21
I only saw it the one time, since I didn't get into the MCU till last year. But I love it! I am actually planning to rewatch it soon, it was amazing in my opinion
CharliHottoyslover2025-11-08 18:24
Hell nah
Original20562025-11-08 18:45
Did you watch the MCU in order?
CaleBoi252025-11-08 21:23
I did :)
klaskc2025-11-08 18:28
Wasted potential boring aaaaaahhhh movie
Arealperson_12025-11-08 18:30
It was fine. If the Thor movies kept the tone of this movie we wouldn’t have love and thunder and a complete joke of the characters associated with him
Dismal-Apricot98892025-11-08 18:37
And I remember walking out of it thinking, “yep, that was a movie.”
LilSwampGod2025-11-08 18:52
I think it gets over hated. It's definitely a bottom rung MCU film, but for Infinity Saga, that makes it an average movie.
Smooth-Mix-43572025-11-08 18:52
Thought it was bad in 2016 (the year I first saw it) and think it is bad now. Endgame at least made me like the film slightly more. Other than Frigga's death and funeral I didn't think much highly about the rest of the film. The dark elves intro was decent. Though Alan Taylor says his original intended vision is much better than the end product. On second thought would Patty Jenkins have made a better film?
evapotranspire2025-11-08 21:05
I would have loved to see the Patty Jenkins version, especially considering that in the version of TDW we did get, the women were secondary at best and hapless objects at worst.
After I rewatched TDW recently, this imbalance really stood out to me. I looked at the credits, and there were NO women in the top-listed production team (writers, directors, etc.). I believe that one of the nine associate producers was a woman, and that was it. So, even including the second-tier production team, it was 95% male. :-/
So would Patty Jenkins have done better? I liked her first Wonder woman movie and did not like her second, so who knows!
Smooth-Mix-43572025-11-08 21:08
Natalie Portman expressed her disappointment when Jenkins wasn't going to direct Thor 2, didn't she?
evapotranspire2025-11-08 21:11
Yes - my understanding is that Portman had a bad experience in this movie which made her not want to participate in future Marvel projects. I can't really say I blame her, considering how they treated her character in Thor 2.
Accomplished-Try99952025-11-08 18:54
Taika Waititi...🤮🤮🤮🤮
omnipresent292025-11-08 18:56
This is the most overhated MCU film
ShawshankHarper2025-11-08 20:15
In comparison yeah
TypeExpert2025-11-08 19:07
This used to be labeled as the worst MCU movie ever. Looking back we were way to harsh because i can name a few movies that have come out since then (specifcally post endgame) that are much much worse in my honest opinion.
Yee_gamer2025-11-08 19:08
I love this movie!
NegotiationNo30132025-11-08 21:45
same!
TrueLegateDamar2025-11-08 19:11
I always found it to be overhated, sure the bad guys were bland(although Kurse was crazy strong) but it had plenty going like the funeral or the portal fight with poor Mjolnir trying to follow Thor.
Palmquistador2025-11-08 19:16
It’s got some weird stuff but it’s a great movie.
Single-Pianist-22112025-11-08 19:20
Thor and Loki are amazing together in TDW. Fantastic chemistry between Chris and Tom and awesome emotional development. Them as a duo needs an entire movie (Thor 5 perhaps)
TheOliveYeti2025-11-08 19:23
Really boring and bland. Not much else to be said.
StevieLong2025-11-08 19:24
Thought this was dope. I liked how it was all about mythology and the norse gods, fucking awesome. No idea why people shit on it.
evapotranspire2025-11-08 20:43
The villain is one-dimensional, his motivations aren't explained, and Natalie Portman is treated like a literal object in the film. For starters. Don't get me wrong, I like the Thor and Loki stuff and the mythology aspects!
Horror-Emotion-95942025-11-08 19:26
It is a bad movie but that poster is INCREDIBLE.
ConnorRoseSaiyan012025-11-08 19:33
Loki was carrying this whole movie but still not good.
Most of the comedy isn't funny. Christopher Eccleston is absolutely wasted and it's just not that appealing on the eyes.
evapotranspire2025-11-08 21:01
OTOH, Malekith had a pretty awesome hairstyle... but that alone was not enough to save his character and the movie....
BravoLeader30002025-11-08 19:48
It has some of my favorite visuals - the Dark Elf space ships are absolutely gorgeous! The final battle where Mjolnir flies from realm to realm because of the Convergence was very creative and amusing.
My biggest criticism is that I wish we'd seen more of Thor and Sif and the Warriors Three at the beginning, rather than having Odin narrate Bor's defeat of the Dark Elves, since we're given the same info again when Thor and Jane go to Asgard after Jane gets infected by the Aether. Alternatively, we could also have gotten some deeper characterization of Malekith, because Eccleston is too good of an actor for what little he was given to work with.
Swifty2552025-11-08 19:49
Way overhated. Definitely lower tier but not that bad.
JocularJupiter2025-11-08 19:52
This movie is great 👍
VelocityReaper2025-11-08 21:08
Only marvel movie I haven’t watched
unclesyrup992025-11-08 21:29
I miss the time when this was considered the worst mcu movie
urbalcloud2025-11-08 22:16
The second worst MCU film after Quantumania, but it’s not that bad. Just a little dull in spots.
Ragnarok_6192025-11-09 01:12
BNW and Marvels exist though
urbalcloud2025-11-09 01:25
Marvels is a blast. Lame villain, but awesome fight scenes. And BNW is a messily edified, decent action film (that’s missing Hulk, for sure.)
Careless_Royal82092025-11-08 22:17
Nevic19842025-11-09 00:31
I don't care what the internet says, I absolutely love this movie. The dark fantasy tone and production design is exactly what I wanted from Thor movie.
Ragnarok_6192025-11-09 01:11
People called this movie the worst, while lapping up some of the post Endgame movies which were arguably worse, both critically and commercially (looking at you, The Marvels).
Cool_Nerd22025-11-09 01:49
I miss the old days when this was considered the worst MCU project.
Commentaires
After I rewatched TDW recently, this imbalance really stood out to me. I looked at the credits, and there were NO women in the top-listed production team (writers, directors, etc.). I believe that one of the nine associate producers was a woman, and that was it. So, even including the second-tier production team, it was 95% male. :-/
So would Patty Jenkins have done better? I liked her first Wonder woman movie and did not like her second, so who knows!
Most of the comedy isn't funny. Christopher Eccleston is absolutely wasted and it's just not that appealing on the eyes.
My biggest criticism is that I wish we'd seen more of Thor and Sif and the Warriors Three at the beginning, rather than having Odin narrate Bor's defeat of the Dark Elves, since we're given the same info again when Thor and Jane go to Asgard after Jane gets infected by the Aether. Alternatively, we could also have gotten some deeper characterization of Malekith, because Eccleston is too good of an actor for what little he was given to work with.