Thor and Captain Rogers lovers went from confident, and amazing characters to later powerful and stronger heroes in the future.

Personally I prefer Peggy as her normal version then herself captain carter one, because their minionifed her way too much for 4 years until What if was done. But overall, go with Jane since she was an active in her first 2 appreances, then was absent for a decade and then came back for her mighty thor cancer story and I think they handled it pretty well, depsite the overall flaws with love and thunder. But seeing her comeback was nice, plus Nataile was awesome in the suit and kicking ass and reteaming with thor aka Hemsworth was nice to both lovers as love of thunders.

Commentaires

AnthropomorphicEggs2025-11-04 02:05

![gif](giphy|pPvznxQ9HSgSjpQVYE)

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-04 02:48

![gif](giphy|3de0sO3gaM4S7aaKk0|downsized)

jpiro2025-11-04 02:09

![gif](giphy|pVXFnPbWn3GZcP8xmf)

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-04 02:49

It's not bad

PhotoBonjour_bombs192025-11-04 06:20

Bad enough to have a stroke

guidethyhandd2025-11-04 03:13

I recognize this art style, is that Johan Liebert?

jpiro2025-11-04 03:19

No idea. Just found the gif.

goodguybolt2025-11-04 13:47

It does look like him in the picture.

guidethyhandd2025-11-05 01:10

Yea I can’t tell if it’s him but it’s definitely from Monster

siestarrific2025-11-04 03:55

I thought they were saying something about Thor and Cap being lovers lol

Neither-Spell-6262025-11-04 14:06

💀

SailorET2025-11-04 14:49

That's not outside the realm of possibility.

Gram-GramAndShabadoo2025-11-08 11:18

They have the same beard.

GingerWez932025-11-04 02:10

Technically, the two pictures of Peggy are two separate characters. Whereas the pictures of Jane are the same character.

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-04 02:50

True.

3v1lkr0w2025-11-04 18:30

I was going to make this exact post...

Ghostpants_2025-11-04 02:12

Hayley Atwell got hotter in 11 years.

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-04 02:48

Yep. So has Portman

the_doughboy2025-11-04 02:17

You left out Rescue/Pepper Pots.

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-04 02:50

She's amazing too

mr90252025-11-05 00:58

Nah brah. Pepper started and ended a hands down badass. Just wore a suit at the end.

TheOliveYeti2025-11-04 02:28

![gif](giphy|mnLZHVpTEbjG1fJydV)

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-04 02:46

![gif](giphy|l0ExvNQOwwJwbz9kI|downsized)

Head_Acanthisitta2562025-11-04 03:02

Just disappointing that the character development to get from point a to point b for both characters has been awful

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-04 03:03

They could've been better

comehereyoudevillog2025-11-04 03:19

Absolutely no one: “We need more strong female characters”

Disney: “best we can do is lazy gender swaps”

Marvel Fans: “please don’t do that”

Disney: “fine, we’ll give their girlfriends powers”

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-04 03:22

Girlfriends are super powerful

comehereyoudevillog2025-11-04 03:24

In their worst appearances in the MCU, yes they are

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-04 03:25

Kind of, but shouldn't been better

EddiezombieAhmet2025-11-04 03:23

Kevin Feige have vandalized Peggy’s legendary life. She was written to be Steve Rogers’ wife despite the 70 years of self-accomplishment demonstrated in Agent Carter, Ant-Man and Agent of Shield.

MulberryEastern50102025-11-04 04:05

To be fair, Captain Carter is of a different Earth

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-04 04:10

True, but if she was written better

DrGutenSexi2025-11-04 07:50

didn't she die in that movie?

thatonemoze2025-11-04 09:43

and had like 3 lines of dialogue

Hobak562025-11-04 19:58

Lmao what. I would argue Peggy Carter in the first avengers was already a highly successful hero. She was no damsel in distress and played a role in winning the war. She is more a hero to me than the half baked captain Carter we got who had 3 lines

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-04 20:04

True. Ww2 peggy is my favourite

zerofrakhere2025-11-04 04:43

And dead

R4cco0n2025-11-04 05:48

Peggy was already portrayed as a strong and self-confident woman in the series Agent Carter. Whereas Jane was actually the princess who needed rescuing in Thor 1 and 2. For her, it was actually an upgrade.

Defiant-Band45732025-11-05 03:40

Thor 2 was especially bad. She was a piece of luggage for most of the movie. She signed on when the director was Patty Jenkins and Jenkins promised that she would get a decent storyline. That was probably one of the reasons she left. Had Portman not been on the hook, she probably would have left after Thor.

statelesspirate0002025-11-04 06:05

That’s comics baby

lsm-krash2025-11-04 07:42

Pepper too!

Solid-Move-14112025-11-04 09:03

Pepper also wore Iron Man suit and defeated more Iron Man villain than Tony Stark

Edit- Genuinely why did I got downvoted lol

AwarenessOk77482025-11-04 09:34

Only Peggy was turned into an annoying Mary Sue.

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-04 12:24

Yep

mrbaryonyx2025-11-05 00:53

Didn't know "appearing on film for two minutes and getting killed" was a Mary Sue

y'all are just applying that to anyone at this point

AwarenessOk77482025-11-05 05:24

I'm talking about "What if", genius

I only apply this to those who are truly Mary Sues. Wanda, Elena, Shuri, and Kate Bishop are not Mary Sues.

marvelcomics222025-11-04 11:12

Agree with Jane, but Peggy not really. She was great as Agent Carter, and Captain Carter as a concept isn't bad, but they essentially made a genderswapped Captain America who happened to be Peggy Carter.

NrFive2025-11-04 12:03

Wasp?

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-04 12:24

That counts

SonOfRageNLove262025-11-04 15:24

I feel like Peggy was more badass in Agent Carter than MoM Captain Carter

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-04 15:24

Oh absolutely

mrbaryonyx2025-11-05 00:52

ah yes, the "love interest--hero--dead" pipeline

Defiant-Band45732025-11-05 03:58

Natalie Portman is an Academy Award winner but you would never know it from her Marvel work. They have never given her any kind of story arc where she could show off her acting skills. Hayley Atwell has been given numerous chances to shine. It is little wonder that Jane is not very popular?

In Thor 2, Portman gets to play a piece of luggage. Is it little wonder she left Marvel? I can see why she would come back in Love and Thunder but her role is much smaller than what was planned. For example, she was supposed to be shown as a hero before Thor came back to earth. That was cut. She was supposed to be shown getting the hammer and she was filmed on wires for that scene but it was cut so the CGI was never finished. There were also scenes where Jane and Val became friends. In the finished film, you can see this. Val knows Mighty Thor is jane. She knows Jane is sick. When Jane joins the fight, the people cheer.

The question that I would ask Feige is why did he bring her back just to kill her off? It doesn't look like she is in any of the upcoming avengers films. What is interesting is that Jane's Thor has a major role in Hickman's Secret Wars when she infiltrates the Thor Corps. Why does Marvel hate Jane so much?

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-05 04:02

I think that they didn't need her again until now, but she will come back in secret wars

Long_Ganache_13352025-11-05 12:55

Don’t forget pepper Potts

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-05 14:55

I haven't

Affectionate-Bus9272025-11-05 13:14

they're powerful and stronger and die

Sammyantoine2025-11-05 19:09

Peggy was already strong the sterm just boost her up a lot

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-05 20:10

Yep exactly

Grayx_28872025-11-07 04:00

Yeah, about that...

The Captain Carter-variant in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness went out like a little pussy after Wanda sliced her in half with her own shield. Jane Foster, as the female Thor...yeah, another victim of bad writing. Especially when you compare her MCU counterpart to her comic book counterpart's run as the lady Thor, thanks to Jason Aaron.

I say Nebula had a better story arc in the MCU than either one of those two.

Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-07 04:42

True. But they turn Captain Carter into a product and Jane sadly was mistread by not great writing, but I prefer her over Carter