Captain America: The First Avenger’s Captain America suit is a better classic suit/homage to the comics than Endgame and Avengers 1.

While Endgame’s suit has the scales on the chest, and Avengers’ suit has the bright colours and big stripes, neither have paid as much attention to Cap’s various comic designs as the First Avenger’s suit has. The boots and the gloves on this suit are the closest they ever got to the comics design in the MCU, featuring the cut in the middle of the glove and the cuffed boots. The white on the arms goes around the entire arm, a design detail which Avengers omitted (it only goes halfway around akin to Spider-Man’s suits) though one which Age of Ultron returned, but was subsequently removed in Civil War. Furthermore, the large pouches on the belt are reminiscent of modern comic designs of Captain America’s belt including Ultimates, unlike later MCU suits which choose to keep the pouches minimal and forgettably small. The gray detailing around the chest/shoulders and the large stars on the shoulders is directly referencing the Ultimates suit.

Voir le contenu lié

Commentaires

rubyschnees2025-11-02 18:32

might be an unpopular opinion, but i don't think everything needs to be an homage to the comics - some things just look (and are) outdated and need an upgrade

killer-cheemstar2025-11-02 18:35

i know; i made this post not to call the endgame suit or any other MCU cap suits bad, i just think i haven’t seen enough appreciation for the detailing and thought behind the design of TFA’s cap suit, especially all the tiny little callbacks it makes to different comic suits.

Dangerous_Teaching622025-11-02 19:48

Genuinely, I can think of a lot of comic book examples that are better the less comic accurate they are. At least from a costume design standpoint.

Deadpools older costume, for example, really sets the characters tone better. And the subtle color differences really make him feel more grounded in a realistic setting. Makes him more scary even.

Also, as someone whose into unique creative interpretations over accurate adaptations, I think the MCU hit it on the head with the mandarin.

Also, lady death was done amazing.

Honestly, the MCU thrives when it's not paying homage

Spiritual-Buffalo8282025-11-02 20:27

ftotally agree, some designs just don’t translate well to the screen anymore

jhsounds2025-11-02 23:18

"With everything that's happening, the things that are about to come to light, people might just need a little old-fashioned."

DefNotAShark2025-11-03 08:48

I always loved this line. Steve’s costume was kind of silly (relative to the other Avengers) and his perspective that it was outdated and weird was realistic. But with this one line it not only makes sense but it creates an emotional argument for why he should have it on that leaves no room for us to question it. It makes you happy hes wearing it.

I know Whedon has a marred legacy but his Avengers script is fucking awesome. It’s so efficient in the beginning in reintroducing the characters, getting to the heart of who they are in these very tidy and well paced scenes. The dialogue does such a good job of building them up, this conversation included.

killer-cheemstar2025-11-02 18:32

forgot to include this in the post; the crosshatch detailing on the shoulders are also an homage to the scales

duxdude4182025-11-02 19:01

Was that stated by the costume designer or just your own inference? It looks like a quilted fabric which—while superficially similiar in shape to the scale mail—really evokes a completely different texture.

killer-cheemstar2025-11-02 19:03

my own inference; it evokes a different texture yes, but when thinking of possible reasons that patterning could’ve been included, considering how much other design aspects of the suit directly evoke aspects of the classic suit such as the aforementioned boots and gloves in the main post, i think the simplest answer is it was in order to evoke the scalemail of the comics while keeping the suit generally practical. i do prefer how endgame eventually went full in on the scalemail, though.

athiestchzhouse2025-11-02 18:38

In endgame, he’s not captain America anymore. He’s just Steve rogers

wandrin_star2025-11-02 18:40

This

Left_Maize8162025-11-02 18:43

Honestly, the Avengers one was the closest apart from his war bonds outfit. All the straps and gray stripes are just so much visual noise and the boots and gloves are brown instead of red in the FA suit. It’s all opinion, but I disagree with you.

killer-cheemstar2025-11-02 18:46

it has a great colour scheme and design layout, but i think when it comes to the smaller detailing it lacks compared to the FA suit. its missing the comic accurate boots and gloves which FA perfectly translated (notice the little cut in the gloves in FA’s suit and the cuffed boots). i think the ideal suit would’ve been the Avengers suit, except with FA’s gloves and boots, the Endgame helmet and scales, and the white going all the way around the arm. of course we didn’t end up getting that unfortunately, but i still love both suits on their own.

killer-cheemstar2025-11-02 18:51

i think [this](https://www.reddit.com/r/marvelstudios/s/2EfCCaBUJn) edit encapsulates what i’m trying to get across here; notice how it utilizes the comic accurate gloves, boots, and belt of the FA suit

Dave-os2025-11-02 18:43

I remember at the time being skeptical of how they were gonna make a live action Captain America suit look believable in a real world setting like how they did with Iron Man, but when I saw the second picture I was like “wow, they actually did it.” His Endgame suit is ultimately my favourite, but this was such a good first suit to introduce him into the universe.

marccass2025-11-02 19:21

It's also kind of cool how he puts together accidentally all of the main components of his look to go out and rescue Bucky. He's still wearing his too from his Bonds show, he picks up some combat pants and boots, steals the 'A' helmet from one of the USA showgirls and he's away.

CountVanillula2025-11-02 20:09

And then he fell onto that train and got the whip from the lion car and then fell into a box of snakes…

iBluefoot2025-11-02 19:40

This was my exact experience as well. I was pleasantly surprised the first movie nailed the suit and had to wait until Endgame for them to improve on that first one.

lanceturley2025-11-02 20:12

I always appreciated how it's not only a good adaptation of Captain America's suit, but it also fits the time period and looks like something a uniform designer in the 1940's could come up with given the styles and materials available then.

Joranthalus2025-11-02 18:46

Pic 4 is when he was played by Big McLargehuge…

wandrin_star2025-11-02 18:47

Potentially unpopular opinion: just about everything in CA:FA was underrated, from the costumes to the “period-evoking” lighting and color mixing to the characterization of the various supporting characters to the villains to the writing to Chris Evans’s performance to Hayley Atwell’s performance. That movie was a *masterpiece* and audiences enjoyed it, but critics overlooked SO MUCH of the depth and thoughtfulness of that movie. I get chills when I think of so many different moments in that film - Erskine pointing at Steve as he is injured, “you said you thought I could be more”, “I’m gonna have to take a raincheck”, “taller” + the involuntary hand, “is this a test?”, etc etc

killer-cheemstar2025-11-02 18:52

agreed, the thought that went into this suit alone encapsulates how much went into the rest of the movie too. remains my favorite captain america film to this day

obscurefalloutboyson2025-11-02 19:16

that movie is SO GOOD and people underrate the hell out of it.

fistkick182025-11-02 21:54

It is also an interesting look into how sequels can **improve** the source material, even if only by nostalgia.

From this movie, we get:
1. "I'm with you til the end of the line" + Bucky's 'death'
2. "I could do this all day"
3. Steve and Peggy's romance
4. Origins of Shield
5. Hydra's infiltration into the US
6. Space Stone
etc.

A ridiculous number of plot points that are fully fleshed out in further movies.

wandrin_star2025-11-02 22:25

Agreed. Adding a few more:

7. Mjolnir’s first appearance, post credits.
8. Red Skull / Soul Stone.
9. The compass.
10. Skinny Steve photo.
11. “This is the guy my dad couldn’t shut up about?”
12. Super soldier serum.
13. Fury gaslighting Steve.
14. Man out of time / throwback / old-fashioned.

_JAD19_2025-11-02 23:16

Mjolnir’s first appearance was the last scene of iron man 2, Thor had already come out when first avenger was released

wandrin_star2025-11-03 16:20

Ah! Shows what I get when I try to do it all from memory.

clashrendar2025-11-02 23:55

First Avenger sets the tone for the rest of the MCU. I appreciate it more and more every time I watch it. It's kind of perfect.

It helps that the same writers were with Steve Rogers for most of his journey from start to end.

Radish-Wrangler2025-11-03 08:15

Don't forget the brief glimpses we get into the Howling Commandos and their missions -- I'm *still* longing for them to get their own miniseries.

Next_Faithlessness872025-11-02 18:48

Question -Is that America's ass?

nerdyoutube2025-11-02 18:57

I think they all have pros and cons. All the straps look cool but definitely separate it from the classic in my mind

Sparkwriter12025-11-02 19:11

Totally agree.

For me personally, it goes

TFA > AoU > Endgame

depastino2025-11-02 19:23

Always thought this was his best suit - tactical, practical and looks fantastic

Vast_Replacement7092025-11-02 19:25

The only Capsuit that looks *good* is the Stealth. ALL of the others look terrible for one reason or another, the Avengers1 the worst of the lot, imho.

Marlowe1262025-11-02 19:29

Pic 3 - That’s AMERICA’s ass!

blodyn__tatws2025-11-02 20:36

That made me laugh. I was scrolling down to see if anyone noticed America's junk on the last pic, or if I need to go straight to the naughty corner.

NegotiationLate85532025-11-02 19:33

I will say it’s the only suit that kind of nailed down the more rugged look for Cap. Given how he’s a super solider I felt like they wanted his costumes to feel to sleek and tight. This suit has a very practical design and I feel like it has greater mobility too. It’s just missing that middle red stripe they added into the TWS Golden Age look.

JonS90_2025-11-02 19:54

I know the whole joke of "throw some straps and satchels on it" , but the choice to have the strapping maroon over a white armour is a pretty great way to translate the look

UnhingedGammaWarrior2025-11-02 20:09

Not better than Endgame, it’s of equal value. Definitely better than Avengers 1

red_army252025-11-03 05:50

The TFA and Endgame suits are just perfect in my mind. Equal but different.

Fancy_Cassowary2025-11-02 20:09

This is a great look for Cap I agree, especially for his first outing. My personal favourite is his Winter Soldier suit, I think that one just ended up looking amazing on screen. If you want to get nitpicky with the First Avenger costume it does get one major thing wrong, and that's the abdomen stripes, though it is done for costume reasons and does look great regardless. Cap's comic look always has a red stripe in the centre, while the FA outfit has a white. One of those things that once you see you can't unsee. Like I said the suit still looks great and it's all incorporated well, but you've got to take a mark off it for that if you want to claim it as the most accurate Cap suit.

saibjai2025-11-02 20:39

First avenger outfit was nice, Avengers endgame was a good evolution as well.

Maximus3612025-11-02 21:11

That was 100% on purpose. MCU movie creators don’t want every movie to reproduce the comics as faithfully as possible.

Capital_Gate67182025-11-02 21:22

My biggest complaint about the First Avenger suit is the sparseness of the stripes on his abdomen, which they fixed with the Smithsonian suit in Winter Soldier

StoneGoldX2025-11-02 22:46

The museum suit from Winter Soldier is still better.

killer-cheemstar2025-11-02 22:59

well yeah its a refined version of the FA suit

StoneGoldX2025-11-02 23:00

The third stripe makes all the difference.

Cabamacadaf2025-11-02 22:50

I love this costume and think it's perfect for the first movie, but it's too much of a military outfit rather than a superhero costume to fit well for the later movies in my opinion.

clashrendar2025-11-02 23:52

I remember seeing the production art for the first time with the First Avenger suit and thinking it was the perfect blend of the comic book and practical real world design. I knew the film was in good hands at that point.

The Winter Soldier Shield stealth outfit is my favorite though. I went a few years before noticing he was wearing it again during the Garden sequence in Endgame.

ckal092025-11-03 00:58

I wonder if OP was alive enough in 2011 to remember

Background_Salt57812025-11-03 02:40

Cap 1’s suit is honestly my favourite out of all of them, followed closely by Infinity War’s “Nomad” suit

Edboy7962025-11-03 03:57

To be fair, the propaganda video he's in and punches Hitler is the real comic accurate suit.

Not suitable for combat, though

Skeeno-TV2025-11-03 12:44

Avengers 1 suit was a massive downgrade

GriffinFTW2025-11-03 16:39

[Here's a ranking of all the live action Captain America suits from one of my favorite YouTube channels.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mNXuisA93nA)

Robey-Wan_Kenobi2025-11-04 01:55

I like how they got the mail texture in the *Endgame* suit.

Particular_Ad_49272025-11-04 15:15

But isn’t his top supposed to be some kind of light chainmail? That was always the impression I got from the comics.