The title change gimmick was cute and fun for AAA in retrospect. At the time I think people were a bit confused.
SP15702025-11-01 15:12
It was a genius move...but so much that few really understood it...
BigMomFriendEnergy2025-11-01 15:34
Kind of like the show in general where it rewards rewatches and didn’t just explain things
Acceptable_Ask69012025-11-01 19:26
yeah for sure, it definitely had everyone scratching their heads at first
TheHondoCondo2025-11-01 21:08
Let’s be honest about it. It probably was going to actually be called Agatha: House of Harkness. They decided Coven of Chaos would be better. Then they didn’t like that either, so they made up this gimmick to save themselves from looking bad in the end.
RenoverO_O2025-11-04 20:12
They wouldn't have called a TV show "Coven of Chaos" unitonically.
It's way too corny and the Chaos Witch isn't even a part of the coven.
House of Harkness would once again put a lot of emphasis on House of M and that barely worked the second time definitely wouldn't have worked the third time.
The gimmick was totally intentional
TheHondoCondo2025-11-04 20:15
They called the show “Agatha All Along” unironically. I don’t think “Coven of Chaos” is any worse than that. So honestly, I think you’re kidding yourself, but I guess we’ll never know for sure.
Gon_Snow2025-11-01 15:22
I miss that show so much. Can’t believe it’s only been a year. Best MCU show since Wandavision which in itself is the best one for me
SlimmyShammy2025-11-01 15:49
It was a neat idea but people pointed at it and went “Marvel can’t even name a show right!!!”
TheHondoCondo2025-11-01 21:09
I think it definitely started as actual name changes, but then they decided to lean into it as a gimmick with “The Lying Witch with Great Wardrobe.”
Agent_14a2025-11-01 15:10
Agatha All Along was supposed to be this marketing thing to sign off with "All Along" name with more weight. So on that logic, it has like 1 change (purple - white theme)
And for What if, I don't see what's the actual "change" here? Barely some 2D-3D change and season name addition being changed a little, not that much cause if we consider even changes on this minute level, might have to add almost all MCU projects...
Gon_Snow2025-11-01 15:21
I think Agatha it was a marketing gag at some point
Little_Setting2025-11-01 20:48
It was, everyone knows that they were building up for the "All Along" part. Not many got it but it was good to sell it like that
StarWarsPlusDrWho2025-11-01 15:45
I’d be curious about the different contexts those What If logos were used in… maybe some were for D23 presentations only and other were for trailers only?
like it feels to me almost like they had two different brand/marketing agencies working separately over the years (maybe one team handled videos and the other handled events/stage presentations, for example), and each team had their own preferred version of the font that they kept using, but didn’t ever coordinate with each other.
(It’s a bit hard to tell the font difference but **specifically** I’m looking at the question mark and how it keeps changing back and forth between two different fonts, but always consistently the same two)
Phoeptar2025-11-01 16:01
Slight colour or glow changes does not a new logo make
bchec2025-11-01 16:07
Was “Agatha: The Lying Witch with Great Wardrobe” actually an announced title at one point? I don’t remember that one.
rechambers2025-11-01 16:27
I might be misremembering but I think they posted and almost immediately deleted it and the official name came quickly after. At this point they were really trying to lean into the gag
bchec2025-11-01 16:48
Ahh, makes sense. 🤝
PhillipJ3ffries2025-11-01 16:30
I don’t get why they always end up with one of the worst versions as the final
Wooden_Passage_26122025-11-01 16:42
I kind of like it
warrenrox992025-11-01 16:42
[technically, Loki clears them all](https://imgur.com/a/dbGCg4e)
And this isn’t even all of them
spanchor2025-11-01 20:27
Eh, I get it, but that’s just a kinetic logo/title. Motion is built in to the design. And I love Loki the show, but the specific title design concept was ripped off from elsewhere.
CloudCitiesonVenus2025-11-02 00:13
Or Ironheart, if you go by the in-show titles
NowWeGetSerious2025-11-01 17:14
And all 3 ended up being fantastic shows
CaleBoi252025-11-01 17:54
Agatha: the Lying Witch with a Great Wardrobe is actually freakin' hilarious oh my word
royalewithcheesecake2025-11-01 19:16
As a graphic designer, sorry to nitpick but the majority of these aren't logo changes, they're different treatments/lockups for the same logo. Even where there *are* arguably logo changes, they're more title updates or fine-tuning rather than any shifts in visual direction. Not saying there haven't been some genuine changes but those are certainly not eleven distinct logos for 'What If...?'
yuvi30002025-11-02 13:55
Yeah, since the logo is treated like a 3D model, some of those seem like just the same moving logo at different points in the animation or under slightly different light while the same logo appears in a different scenario.
I also wouldn't count the season subtitle as part of the logo change. For Agatha, it was potentially the entire show's name changing, whether part of a marketing gimmick or not. But simply adding a bit of text to announce a new season isn't really a logo change in my eyes.
RacerXX72025-11-01 19:24
I'm waiting for "What Now?" S1.
ZacPensol2025-11-02 10:14
I think I'll skip that and just wait for "How 'Bout...?" S1
BackgroundEngineer112025-11-01 20:59
I never saw Lying Witch with Great Wardrobe, that's awesome.
Also I'm having trouble seeing the majority of differences in the *What If...* logos.
xdrkcldx2025-11-01 21:30
And they’re arguably the worst. Coincidence?
The_Beatz2025-11-01 21:37
Moment of silence for Sionque
Kooky_Razzmatazz_3482025-11-01 23:48
Agents of Shield had a lot of changes, but it did have 7 seasons. [https://www.reddit.com/r/shield/comments/idcwla/the\_title\_cards\_of\_agents\_of\_shield\_excluding](https://www.reddit.com/r/shield/comments/idcwla/the_title_cards_of_agents_of_shield_excluding)
Edboy7962025-11-02 02:32
Those artists had their work cut out for them
Everyoneheresamoron2025-11-02 03:36
\*laughs in Agents of Shield\*
Grandturk-1822025-11-02 13:36
So?
The_Orgin2025-11-02 17:12
Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. has them all beat.
Hufa1232025-11-02 20:12
Agents of SHIELD had 30 different title logos. Pretty sure that's more than any of these.
jaxomlotus2025-11-04 18:40
"Lying witch with the great wardrobe" is some A++++ top tier marketing
Commentaires
It's way too corny and the Chaos Witch isn't even a part of the coven.
House of Harkness would once again put a lot of emphasis on House of M and that barely worked the second time definitely wouldn't have worked the third time.
The gimmick was totally intentional
And for What if, I don't see what's the actual "change" here? Barely some 2D-3D change and season name addition being changed a little, not that much cause if we consider even changes on this minute level, might have to add almost all MCU projects...
like it feels to me almost like they had two different brand/marketing agencies working separately over the years (maybe one team handled videos and the other handled events/stage presentations, for example), and each team had their own preferred version of the font that they kept using, but didn’t ever coordinate with each other.
(It’s a bit hard to tell the font difference but **specifically** I’m looking at the question mark and how it keeps changing back and forth between two different fonts, but always consistently the same two)
And this isn’t even all of them
I also wouldn't count the season subtitle as part of the logo change. For Agatha, it was potentially the entire show's name changing, whether part of a marketing gimmick or not. But simply adding a bit of text to announce a new season isn't really a logo change in my eyes.
Also I'm having trouble seeing the majority of differences in the *What If...* logos.