Tony's snap
Please advise me if i missed something but i just rewatched most of the mcu movies and i have questions
Soul stone deaths are irreversible i know but we also know the stones can bring back dusted deaths which are atomized deaths, likewise time stone alone brought back a destroyed vision. REMEMBER, VISION WAS TORN TO SHREDS AND LITERALLY EXPLODED to million pieces
After tony snaps, why couldnt any of the strong guys
1. Why couldnt someone use the stones to cure tony and remove the snap destruction in his body? If the stobe can dust a person to atoms, why cant they HEAL NOT REWIND THE SNAP WOUNDS BUT HEAL THE SNAP WOUND ATOMS in his body? If the stones are powerful enough to inflict the wound, it is powerful enough to remove the wound. The same way there is no power to destroy the stones but themselves can destroy themselves
2. Why couldnt someone use the stones and transfer tony's conciousness to a constructed something? The same way vision was created? Remember vision itself was not yet existing but it was managed to be created by the mind stone, here we are talking about transferring tony's soult to existing one to another thing. Someone could just snap a robot with his soul1 there. Especially the mindstone itself was powerful enough to create vision, here 6 stones are more than enough to do a lesser task of transfering, not create since the stones are powsrful enough already to revive or delete souls not triggered by soul stone deatha
3. Why coulsnt someone use the stones to make a clone of tony ? Be it from memory or from the timestone prior to tony's snap or anything? Reality stone can be used that their are two identical tonys? Doesent matter if one tony dies and the other is alive becauae it would still be a continuation of tony in 2 different but identical bodies. Likewise tony is smart enough to accept the fact that the 1st tony accepta his death as everything ia correctrd and morgan gets to live, likewise the 2nd tong realizes the new life he is given sith and will not wastw it
Basically they are already dealing with life, death, stones, souls, creation and deletion. So many feats have been done that are seemingly more complex then transffering a soul or creating a clone of someone.
I assume the impact on hulk is way lesser because this is 1 soul or small feat as compared to resurrecting all the dusted ones which are trillions. This means the impact ia elss and somekne like maybe thor or captain marvel can manage a lesser feat .
Soul stone deaths are irreversible i know but we also know the stones can bring back dusted deaths which are atomized deaths, likewise time stone alone brought back a destroyed vision. REMEMBER, VISION WAS TORN TO SHREDS AND LITERALLY EXPLODED to million pieces
After tony snaps, why couldnt any of the strong guys
1. Why couldnt someone use the stones to cure tony and remove the snap destruction in his body? If the stobe can dust a person to atoms, why cant they HEAL NOT REWIND THE SNAP WOUNDS BUT HEAL THE SNAP WOUND ATOMS in his body? If the stones are powerful enough to inflict the wound, it is powerful enough to remove the wound. The same way there is no power to destroy the stones but themselves can destroy themselves
2. Why couldnt someone use the stones and transfer tony's conciousness to a constructed something? The same way vision was created? Remember vision itself was not yet existing but it was managed to be created by the mind stone, here we are talking about transferring tony's soult to existing one to another thing. Someone could just snap a robot with his soul1 there. Especially the mindstone itself was powerful enough to create vision, here 6 stones are more than enough to do a lesser task of transfering, not create since the stones are powsrful enough already to revive or delete souls not triggered by soul stone deatha
3. Why coulsnt someone use the stones to make a clone of tony ? Be it from memory or from the timestone prior to tony's snap or anything? Reality stone can be used that their are two identical tonys? Doesent matter if one tony dies and the other is alive becauae it would still be a continuation of tony in 2 different but identical bodies. Likewise tony is smart enough to accept the fact that the 1st tony accepta his death as everything ia correctrd and morgan gets to live, likewise the 2nd tong realizes the new life he is given sith and will not wastw it
Basically they are already dealing with life, death, stones, souls, creation and deletion. So many feats have been done that are seemingly more complex then transffering a soul or creating a clone of someone.
I assume the impact on hulk is way lesser because this is 1 soul or small feat as compared to resurrecting all the dusted ones which are trillions. This means the impact ia elss and somekne like maybe thor or captain marvel can manage a lesser feat .
Commentaires
Basically there would have been consequences.
Was just bugging me. I understand some will argue curing tony of the wound would cancel his sacrifice. But aside from my 1st question. The 2nd and 3rd arent curing him becauae the wound is still in the original body. So this is basically making a new body for tonys soul or new clone of tony thereby the oriignal tony body with snap wound is still existing which means the after effects wasnt cured.
Mainly because i just read gantz and there was a time two copies of the same character existed whicj i remembered during endgame.
For 2 and 3 is kinda messed up to stick him in a construct with out talking it over also what construct are you talking about there isn't anything there or time to make one and on top of that word making one?
Lastly nobody there is strong enough to do it with out repercussions beat care you sacrifice one to save him
But i guess the strong one to snap that you commented is true. Was banking on captain marvel at least. Or maybe the impact if hulk uses it again is lessened because thd initial snap was trillion zillion souls, now its just one soul so i was thinking the law of equivalent exchange
Just morally is Grey
But yea captin marvel may be able to do it but depending on what the gauntlet did to him when he snapped and removed Thanos and all of the others.
By your law of equivalent exchange wouldnt that mean the damage done to his body and soul would equate to all of Thanos army?
Yeah if i recall, captain marvel has some tesseract influence on her powers right? So that is maybe similar to gamma radiation so if bruce is filled with gamma radiation and survives 1 snap, maybe capt marvek with some tesseract energies also same result
For the damage, maybe it was duration based. just figured because thanos and hulk seemed tk have the same level of damage i think as they are the same size, and tony has mkre damage being smaller frame 🤣
I assume captain marvel can because she presumably has tesseract energy inside her which might work the same way a bit similar to gamma radiation from the stones that same energu circulates inside hulk
Imagine that discussion. They're sitting around and it's like "well, Thor could survive, he's a god" and Thor goes "I am, indeed, the last god of Asgard. None others remain" and they decide not to fully genocide his pantheon. Then Carol? "If it kills me, who will take up my burden?" Hulk nearly died already. Everyone else is basically just another human or an otherwise regular alien and might certainly die, so who? Scott has a daughter, T'challa is the last Panther, Hawkeye has a family, Wanda is enslaving a town, Steve is planning to plow Peggy, Peter is 16, there's no one superfluous enough to swap for Tony
Or just being near that many stones when they are close to each other, no matter what is holding them. The universe wouldn't require an intelligent species to develop and then invent a glove to activate them with a finger snap.